Posted on 12/23/2004 4:33:47 AM PST by Jalapeno
A national Islamic organization has demanded an apology from a Texas-based private school association after claiming its director took an "alarmingly intolerant and hostile attitude toward Islam and Muslims."
The protest by the Washington, D.C.-based Council on American-Islamic Relations was prompted by a letter sent by the Texas Association of Private and Parochial Schools to the representatives of an Islamic school in Houston.
Dar-Ul-Arqam, which enrolls more than 300 students at three area locations under the supervision of the Islamic Education Institute of Texas, has been seeking membership for its Adel Road campus in the private school association, known as TAPPS. The association includes 238 schools across the state, including Awty International School, Incarnate Word Academy, Northland Christian School and St. Thomas High School in the Houston area.
Membership typically expands opportunities for private-school students to compete against other schools in academic and athletic events.
The letter, apparently signed by TAPPS Director Edd Burleson, has the American Civil Liberties Union of Texas calling for an investigation, according to Alamdar Hamdani, a Houston member of the ACLU board. The Anti-Defamation League also has expressed concern.
In his correspondence, Burleson quoted a verse from the Quran as calling on Muslims to be violent toward Christians and Jews. He noted that most TAPPS member schools are Christian. "Why do you wish to join an organization whose membership is basically in total disagreement with your religious beliefs?" he asked in the two-page letter, which included 10 questions.
He asks about the school's attitude toward "the spread of Islam in America" and the goals of the school "in this regard."
Finally, he suggests that some TAPPS members may not be tolerant of Muslims: "Why do you think that the current member schools of TAPPS will not be biased against your school, based on the fundamental difference in your religion and Christianity, since about 90% of TAPPS schools embrace Christianity?"
Both the TAPPS office and most member schools were closed Wednesday because of the holiday. Burleson did not return phone messages or e-mails this week. Charles Price, the chairman of the TAPPS board, declined to comment, referring all questions to Burleson.
Iesa Galloway, the executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations' Houston office, said Burleson sent a similar letter to an Islamic school in the Dallas area. He said he was awaiting details of that case.
Besides demanding an apology, Galloway's group has asked for reprimands against those responsible for the letter.
"The TAPPS letter, a symbol of religious intolerance, has no place in a nation that was originally built by those seeking asylum from such intolerance," Galloway said in correspondence he sent this week to the TAPPS board.
Dar-Ul-Arqam's Adel Road campus enrolls some 175 students and already participates in the Grapevine-based Private School Interscholastic Association, according to Khaled Katbi, a school representative.
But that association's programs are only available through middle school. So representatives of Dar-Ul-Arqam began looking for an association that would offer scholastic competition for its 19 high school students.
On Nov. 4, Katbi went before the TAPPS board to seek membership for his school. Board members asked him if the school taught from the Quran, and Katbi said it did.
"Their questions were reasonable," Katbi said. "I did not sense hostility."
A week later, Katbi got a letter from Burleson that included questions Burleson said the school needed to answer before it could be admitted to TAPPS.
"Do you teach your students to 'Make war on them (Christians and Jews) until idolatry is no more and Allah's religion reigns supreme' (Koran 8:37)?" Burleson asked.
Katbi said he was "astonished" by the letter. He did not reply to the questions.
The bylaws of TAPPS do not indicate that the organization is open only to Christian schools.
Hamdani, the ACLU representative, said the organization would come under special restrictions if it accepts federal funding. But the TAPPS Web site indicates that the nonprofit organization relies on dues from member schools and sporting-event fees.
"It's the venom in that letter that's so disturbing," Hamdani said. While the letter is structured as a series of questions, he said, "they're really more assumptions than questions."
Martin B. Cominsky, regional director of the Anti-Defamation League, said the letter "assumes some offensive stereotypes about what Islam is all about."
Ibrahim Hooper, spokesman for the Council on American-Islamic Relations in Washington, D.C., said he was not aware of any other cases in which Islamic schools had difficulty joining private-school organizations.
He said the letter reflects "the rise in anti-Muslim sentiment" that has emerged since the terrorist attacks of 2001.
This is why vouchers are such a terrible idea. They will be immediately used by the Islamists to isolate and brainwash their children.
What does "private" mean?
Katbi said he was "astonished" by the letter. He did not reply to the questions.
Couldn't answer the question, eh?
For muslims to speak of religious intolerance is laughable considering how Christians are treated in muslim countries.
That letter askes pertinent questions about Islam that muslims can't truely answer without showing the dark side of Islam.
I thought the whole point of private schools was to avoid all the PC diversity garbage-this person needs to just go away.
GOOD FOR HIM!!!!
"This is why vouchers are such a terrible idea. They will be immediately used by the Islamists to isolate and brainwash their children."
Agreed.
CAIR is a bunch of whiners. I guess that is what the group has to resort to when they have no political influence. Let's hope it stays that way.
ANSWER THE QUESTIONS!!!!
Sounds like the letter mostly quoted the Koran.
Then again, the Koran is a pretty venomous book, so I guess I shouldn't be surprised.
Is there any where we can read the entire letter?
Katbi said he was "astonished" by the letter. He did not reply to the questions.
You'd have to be blind, deaf, and idiotic not to see what's going on here. But I guess that's why we have liberals.
Diagree completely with you.
NOW, my tax dollars are used by the NEA-Islamo-fascist wannabes to "isolate and brainwash" children.
At least under a voucher program, the parents can CHOOSE which school to send their kids.
I see NO DIFFERENCE between the current public school and an Islamic madrassa.
1) They're already brainwashing their children.
2) Voucher legislation could be written to exclude institutions where the violent overthrow of the US government is advocated, or institutions that militate against Constitutionally protected freedoms.
3) 90% of the school-age population is sent to government schools. The vast majority of these children will graduate without understanding the threat posed by militant Islam. Under a voucher program, a large number of these children will be transferred to Christian or Hebrew schools where they will be more likely to learn about the true nature of Islam, and be better equipped to deal with it.
So answer them and dispel the assumptions. Without seeing the letter I can't comment on whether there was actual "venom," but I can say that I have been underwhelmed at the chorus of condemnation of American Muslims to the terrorist tactics of Muslims in the rest of the world. This is a great opportunity to tell the members of TAAPS that all of Islam isn't like that.
Unless it is.
Martin B. Cominsky, regional director of the Anti-Defamation League, said the letter "assumes some offensive stereotypes about what Islam is all about."
Stereotypes encouraged by such things as the bombing of the World Trade Center, shelling markets, and beheading innocents? Why would anyone hold such stereotypes? Whatever we do, let's not spend a minute looking at where those stereotypes might come from. Blaming the religious group for the impression it has given the world is only allowed for Christians.
Shalom.
Shalom.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.