[muawiyah]

Well, at 300 db he'd be playing it in my house wouldn't he.

Again, the point is made ~ it was her house, not his, and he went outside to see if he could hear it.

[Mr. Silverback]

This guy didn't have a psychic flash that there was swearing going on and run outside. His kid could hear it on the street outside Herb's house. If she were playing music that loud, she might be violating a perfectly legal noise ordinance.

Sorry, but this is not a case of a judge riding to the rescue to protect the American's home-as-castle. This is the case of idiot without self-control running afoul of an idiotic (but constitutional) law.