[BlueStateBlues]

I nominate the “cardboard box”, one of the most enduring toys for every generation. Along with the Ant Farm, of course.

[Tax-chick]

Cardboard Box was the winner in 2005, according to the article. I think the stick is a great choice.

[shadeaud]

Don’t forget the hula hoop

[Sybeck1]

I nominate “pots and pans” to go alongside their combo brother “the stick”. Great music there...............

But don’t forget “rock” and “dirt clod”..........