[Izzy Dunne]

So where was this question a year ago?

[ridesthemiles]

So where was this question a year ago?””

Philip J Berg filed a lawsuit on August 22, 2008.

It was dismissed by the court judge stating that Mr Berg ‘Had no standing”.

There have been at least 25 threads on this topic since then.

[El Gato]

So where was this question a year ago?

Same as now, being dismissed in various courts for techincal reasons. Standing, ripeness, political question. Whatever the judge could come up with that didn't sound too bad.