Posted on 04/01/2010 9:07:25 AM PDT by DCBryan1
Truck fire took toddler’s life
She was strapped into seat to die, affidavit says
JACOB QUINN SANDERS ARKANSAS DEMOCRAT-GAZETTE
Hannah Grace Dowdie was alive in her father’s truck when it was set afire, his body lying in its bed after he was slain for failing to pay debts, according to unsealed Pulaski County sheriff’s records obtained Wednesday.
The fire killed the girl, weeks away from her second birthday.
The records depict for the first time publicly what sheriff’s office investigators believe happened Dec. 12 to the child and her father, Michael Palmer, 28, after they drove from his home in Hensley toward Sweet Home and before their bodies were found burned beyond recognition in his small 1988 GMC pickup on dead-end Wilbern Road.
The documents also reveal for the first time some of the evidence investigators found to implicate the two cousins they arrested — including statements that Hannah was alive when she was strapped into her car seat and the truck set ablaze.
Investigators and prosecutors requested in January that Pulaski County District Judge Wayne Gruber seal sworn affidavits for search warrants and arrest warrants because releasing such details as how Palmer and his daughter died could harm their case. Gruber unsealed the records Friday.
Sheriff Doc Holladay said that when he learned the records would become public, he told investigators to contact relatives of Palmer and his daughter to let them know what was coming.
“I didn’t feel it was appropriate for them to read that in the paper or see it on the news without hearing it from us first,” Holladay said. He said the documents are not easy to read, even for a longtime law-enforcement officer.
“It’s hard for me, so I can only imagine what it’s like for the family,” he said. “We know that it’s going to be difficult to understand how someone could do something like that to anyone, especially a small child. But our role is to investigate it and make sure the people responsible are in jail.”
Robert Todd Gatrell, 20, and his cousin, Daniel Chase Gatrell, 16, are charged with arson and capital murder in the killings.
The older Gatrell’s attorney, Hubert Alexander, did not reply to a message seeking comment. Mark Hampton, who represents the younger Gatrell, said he had not yet read the documents and could not comment.
Palmer took his daughter — in foster care until a judge gave him custody the day before — when he headed to Shamburger Lane and the home of Robert Todd Gatrell, who goes by his middle name, according to a sworn arrest warrant affidavit. Palmer called him twice before going over, according to the affidavit.
When investigators first talked to Gatrell the day of the killings, he denied that Palmer had called him, saying it had been two days since they talked. Then he changed his story, according to the affidavit.
“Mr. Gatrell said that during the second call, Mr. Palmer told Mr. Gatrell that he was coming to Gatrell’s residence to visit and to steal some tires from Mr. Gatrell’s grandfather’s residence, which is next door to his, for his vehicle,” sheriff’s office Sgt. Mike Blain wrote in the affidavit.
Gatrell also would not allow investigators to search his property that first day they talked to him, according to the affidavit, but he called back several hours later to give permission.
Lynette Beeson, a former girlfriend of Palmer’s, told investigators that Palmer had borrowed an all-terrain vehicle from Gatrell and sold it without giving Gatrell any of the money. She added that several weeks before dying, Palmer had gotten tires from Gatrell and never paid for them.
After his arrest, Gatrell told investigators that he and his cousin only tried to scare Palmer into paying them for other things he’d stolen, according to the affidavit.
Blain wrote in the affidavit that each Gatrell offered a different story to family members and investigators, each blaming the other.
One of Daniel Gatrell’s uncles, Thomas Floyd, said to investigators that his nephew told him that Robert Todd Gatrell called him when Palmer was on his way over.
“Daniel stated that Todd Gatrell advised him that a shotgun was on the back porch of his residence and directed Daniel to get the shotgun to protect the property,” Blain wrote in the affidavit.
Palmer met up with Robert Todd Gatrell and the two walked around the corner of a shed, where Daniel Gatrell was waiting, according to the affidavit. Palmer saw the shotgun and grabbed it, but it went off, wounding him in the abdomen, according to the affidavit.
“Daniel advised that at that time, he was ‘frozen’ in shock and Todd Gatrell stated that Mr. Palmer was not dead and for him to shoot him again,” Blain wrote. “Daniel advised that he could not shoot the weapon again and at that point, Todd took the weapon from him and shot Mr. Palmer again in the abdomen. Daniel advised that Todd then kicked the victim and said that he was still alive.”
Then Robert Todd Gatrell shot Palmer in the head, according to the affidavit.
Two days after his Jan. 21 arrest, Robert Todd Gatrell told investigators that his cousin fired three shots at Palmer in quick succession and killed him without any help after coming out of hiding from behind the shed, according to the affidavit.
The affidavit said the cousins’ accounts are consistent in describing what happened to Palmer’s body. They dropped the body in the bed of Palmer’s truck and tossed a couple wooden pallets on top and a bleach-soaked rug near the tailgate to keep blood from spilling out, according to the affidavit.
The Gatrells differ again, however, about how Palmer’s daughter got into the truck’s cab, according to the affidavit.
Hannah was inside Robert Todd Gatrell’s house playing with his girlfriend’s daughter when her father died, according to the affidavit. One version of the story told to investigators has the Gatrells walking inside, with Todd looking at the child and back at his cousin.
“No,” Daniel Gatrell told his cousin, according to the affidavit.
“Daniel advised that Todd stated to him that she (Hannah) was evidence and they needed to get rid of her,” Blain wrote in the affidavit, attributing the statements again to Daniel’s uncle, Floyd.
Robert Todd Gatrell strapped her into a child’s seat in the truck’s cab, according to the affidavit.
In his own statement after his arrest, Robert Todd Gatrell did not say who put Hannah in the truck, only that he drove it the half-mile to Wilbern Road near Granite Mountain Quarries.
Floyd told investigators his nephew said it was only Robert Todd Gatrell who poured gasoline on Palmer’s body and inside the truck’s cab. Robert Todd Gatrell told investigators he and Daniel Gatrell poured the gasoline and lit it.
Palmer and his daughter were unrecognizable when firefighters put out the fire. The fire burned both Gatrells as well, according to the affidavit.
Investigators found nails in the truck’s bed that looked like they may have come from wooden pallets, according to the affidavit. An autopsy confirmed that Palmer died from shotgun wounds made with 12-gauge Remington shells, size No. 4. Hannah died from burns and smoke inhalation.
Four days after the killings, Pulaski County sheriff’s Deputy Steve Morgan got a call from Robert Todd Gatrell, his stepson.
“Mr. Morgan advised that on December 16, 2009, Todd Gatrell contacted him via telephone and advised him that he was suicidal and had placed a shotgun in his mouth on this date,” Blain wrote in the affidavit.
There were nightmares, too, according to the affidavit, “where he hears Hannah crying as she is burning in the vehicle.”
The next day, Morgan drove his stepson to Baptist Health Medical Center in Little Rock, according to the affidavit. Morgan also took three guns — a 12-gauge shotgun, a 20-gauge shotgun and a .50-caliber black-powder rifle — out of the house for “safekeeping,” according to the affidavit.
After cooperating with the investigation, Morgan resigned from the sheriff’s office Jan. 26.
Investigators got Robert Todd Gatrell’s medical records with a search warrant. At the hospital, he was treated for suicidal and homicidal thoughts as well as seconddegree burns on his lower back.
According to the affidavit, he told several people he got the burns lighting trash on his property.
Blain and other investigators served their first search warrants Jan. 6 at the two Gatrell properties on Shamburger Road. According to inventories released Wednesday, they took leaves they thought might be stained with blood, plastic oil containers, a red plastic gasoline container and a 12-gauge Remington shotgun shell, size No. 4.
They also found mail addressed to Palmer from the state Department of Finance and Administration about his 1988 GMC pickup and a CD holder “with painted writing on the back that states ‘Lynette B (heart) Michael P Always.’”
With Robert Todd Gatrell already in jail, investigators went back with another search warrant Jan. 25 and found what they thought could be blood.
They went back again the next day, arresting Daniel Gatrell and finding a black wallet belonging to Palmer down a well, according to that warrant’s inventory.
“You don’t get to pick and choose the circumstances you’re confronted with,” Holladay said. “You just do the best you can and send the bad guys to jail, and we’re confident we’ll be able to do that in this case.”
Yup, fry ‘em. But remember these are not the first perps of Arkansides - fry ‘em all.
I can’t think of ANY good reasons to be against the death penalty.
Problems with “innocents” facing the death penalty are caused by the court system, not the death penalty.
Its called the “off switch.” At my home we use it a lot.
BTW, part of your post doesn’t make much sense. The Male Dominated Middle East, esp. Iran, is the very part of the world that considers us The Great Satan.
Also, many of the media products from foreign countries make ours look pretty mild.
True enough, but the results are the same.
They almost fried themselves. Article says they both had burns.
Liberals want the parents to bear complete responsibility for policing media, which kids see at their friends' houses, over the internet while searching in school and public libraries, and now easily downloaded over iPod and iPhone touch screens. Media includes billboards, books and magazines displayed in groceries and Walmarts, video games, and entertainment venues like the glorified pinball parlors in malls, amusement parks, and even the movie posters and titles publicly displayed at theaters, in theater trailers for coming attractions, and inserted into ads during decent programming. There is no off switch for many of these things. My family and I were grossed out by ads and coming attractions when we went to see "The Passion of the Christ" in a theater. Even Bill O'Reilly shows clips of partially-bleeped nudity by pop icons like Lady Gaga and Erikah Badu. It's everywhere.
BTW, part of your post doesn’t make much sense. The Male Dominated Middle East, esp. Iran, is the very part of the world that considers us The Great Satan.
You had a reading comprehension issue: That's exactly what I said.
We’ve also raised a generation of judges who seem hell-bent on destroying civilization. This poor little baby was given back to her father out of foster care ONE DAY before she was horrifically murdered. Obviously there was some solid reason she’d been taken away and put in foster care in the first place, and I simply don’t believe that a proper investigation of whether the father had become fit to parent a toddler again, could have come up with a “yes” answer for this guy.
SLOWLY!!!!!
God help me, I could gleefully inflict about twenty years of slow, agonizing, torture upon the Gatrell brothers.
God is just. Vengeance is His, He will repay.
I’ve been reading and hearing a lot of horrific acts done to children in the last few months. It just breaks my heart to hear about it and I pray to God for an end to such things.
I advocate a quick execution for such monsters, so that their Almighty Creator can administer true justice of the kind and degree we cannot even fathom.
What is there to say?
This event speaks about the state of this country and its inhabitants in ways I don’t even want to begin to describe.
It would be nice if those monsters had to endure what she went through for eternity on top of their burning.
Evil is running rampant as I’ve never seen it.
I know that it’s not the worst people have done to each other throughout history, but the breakdown of our culture and society is becoming unbelievable and I agree with your sentiments.
It’s a start......
Expedient in time, slow in doing.
No amount of good works in the world can ever outweigh this single act of evil.
CPS really need to stop placing these children in the homes of the parents before allowing further investgation. There is to much of this going on just in this state alone ! god help our children, this world is a sick and dying place!!!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.