I’m no gun expert, but an M1 is a tricky proposition, and heavy to boot. The Springfield is perfect for drill and ceremonial purposes. If they have to have something newer why not an M-14? They seemed fairly simple compared to an M1.
In America it ASSUMED that top-down management is the best. This is an excellent example of why it is important to obtain “ground truth” BEFORE a military “suit” makes the typical “One Size Fits All” decision.
The function of the gun used is to give the final salute to our deceased warriors. “Going Modern” is about as disrespectful as one can get to these deceased men and women.
From an historical point of view, I would prefer that the Squad use the same weapons, including repairs, for as long as the squad is needed.
____________
To the bone-headed officer or civilian who made this micro manager, one-size-fits-all decision, on behalf of myself, and any another other, VERY intelligent, ( you must be intelligent if you agree with ME ), Vet., I hereby award, with all rights and privileges, the Distinguished Susan B. Anthony Silver Dollar Award for 2011, in the Year of Our Lord.
Squad! Tin-Hut! Ready, - - - !!!!! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Not AT the micromanager!