Posted on 11/24/2013 12:53:18 PM PST by Dysart
I have a faded sticker on the back of my car that reads: I (heart) Scotland. I have a feeling it was stuck there by some fellows from Strathclyde police when they came down to help with the Notting Hill carnival, and I keep it there because it reflects my general feelings. I (heart) Scotland in the way that so many of us Sassenachs do: you know, fabulous place, lovely people, gorgeous purple moors, great white beaches and an incomparable contribution to Western thought and civilisation, from Adam Smith to Andrew Neil.
I (heart) Scotland so much that I once made a doomed attempt to become rector of a Scottish university, in which I destroyed a massive poll lead by announcing that I was not only English but in favour of top-up fees, and ended up coming third and having beer poured over my head. But still I (heart) Scotland. I (heart) the bagpipes and the porridge and the view from Arthur’s Seat and swimming with seals and the funny prehistoric cows with ginger fringes and the see-you-Jimmy tam-o’-shanter that I keep as a memento of one holiday; and so I find it positively (heart) breaking to find that serious people are now worried that the union between England and Scotland – a gigantic political fact for 306 years – is under threat.
Never mind the sentiment, the fuzzy warm feelings I have about the place. Whatever happens, tourism will continue, after all. We are on the verge of losing something even more precious – to both Scotland and England – and I don’t think people have woken up to the full lunacy of what is afoot. In its desultory complacency, the conversation reminds me of some middle-aged couple deciding to get divorced.
(Excerpt) Read more at telegraph.co.uk ...
Is this proposed split 1) likely 2) a win-win? more favorable to Scotland or England? lose-lose?
My best guess is the positions on disunion from the man-on-the-street vs the more engaged political activists-- for or agin-- are varied and for different reasons.
A divorce from the Leftists would be smart, blessed and successful.
It’d be very good for England to be rid of all those Labour and other leftist MPs that Scotland sends.
I believe the Conservative Party would have a slight majority right now, less the Scottish MPs, only 1 of whom is a Tory.
Yes Cameron sucks but he’d suck less without his Lib Dem coalition partners.
Given that the Scottish National Party is hardcore socialist, I suspect that a breakup of the Union would be a disaster for Scotland.
It’s hard to, at the very least, foresee how it wouldn’t result in economic shock, initially, for the Scots.
Who gives a damn about the ‘conservative’ party? Scotland leaving would boost UKIP, who while not perfect, are Britain’s only chance of survival.
Funny though, with Scotland on its own, it would become a Soviet state. They’d do school exchanges with North Korea.
Oh, yes. Scotland would be Greece in a couple of months. They’d also be forced to adopt the Euro. haha
It’d be worth it if it kept the Muslims out of Scotland.
Oh, no doubt. It’s when they’ve settled down and gotten their bearings, though, that the disaster would really begin.
Those are two disturbing images.
I have the DVD of Michael Powell’s “The Edge of the World” about the Island of St. Kilda.
There is also an interview of his widow. One thing she mentions is how much he loved Scotland tho he was English. She said when he finished a movie, he would always take a few weeks off and hike around Scotland.
His friend who would go with him was the editor of “The Scotsman” newspaper tho I can’t recall his name.
Scottish ping...
5 million Leftist removed from the British electorate would be a boon to England and the Anglo-American alliance.
I'm not sure our own track record of settling matters of secession amicably is much of an advertisement. "Manage it with 600,000 fewer deaths than we did!" is probably good advice but it lacks a little in specificity...
There is Scots blood in my veins, so I love this stuff. ;>)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.