Posted on 07/31/2016 10:19:26 PM PDT by Impala64ssa
Everyone’s talking about the speech delivered by Mr. Khizr Khan, accompanied by his wife Ghazala at the DNC that focused on the loss of his son, U.S. Army Captain Humayan Khan.
It appears things have devolved into such a level of immaturity relating to the speech that I believe there’s a need for a clear analysis of Mr. Khan’s address, and what he should have presented.
First, let me offer my condolences to the Khan family for their sacrifice, as they are now an American Gold Star Family. Their son and I share an unbreakable bond. We both served our nation and, along with three other generations in my family, took the oath to support and defend our Constitution and served in combat zones.
Yes sir, Mr. Khan, I’ve read our Constitution and firmly recognize the preeminent responsibility of our federal government is to “provide for the common defense.” I also comprehend the relationship between the three branches of government…you know separation of powers, checks and balances, coequal branches of government.
I would offer a simple recommendation to Mr. Khan. Perhaps you should have asked President Barack Obama if he had read the Constitution — undoubtedly you would agree we have witnessed a few unconstitutional actions from him.
And while you were at it, Mr. Khan, perhaps you could have asked Hillary Clinton about handling classified information — since I’m quite sure your son, Captain Khan, had at a minimum a secret clearance.
I don’t think your son would have been able to, well, have his “careless” mishandling of classified materials and information simply excused. Perhaps Mr. Khan, you could have addressed the necessity for high standards of honor, integrity, and character in a commander in chief.
Also, I found it interesting Mr. Khan, that you and your wife, an American Gold Star family, would take the stage to support a sitting president and one desiring to be president, who had abandoned Americans in a combat zone and lied about it.
I tend to believe that if alive, your son would consider that type of behavior abhorrent and deplorable. Or perhaps, as it seems, your speech was politically driven, and not based on principle? After all, you did take the stage before a crowd that disrespected a Medal of Honor recipient…is that cool with you?
You see, I understand Mr. Khan, that your son and your family are Muslim and Muslims do indeed serve in our armed forces. But in the military I know, we do not celebrate that which divides, but rather that which unites. And what is it that unites us as Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen, and Marines? It is service above self, commitment to something greater than the individual, and sacrifice for our country and comrades in arms.
Now, let’s be honest Mr. Khan, those of us with knowledge could just as easily bring attention to SGT Hasan Karim Akbar and Major Nidal Hasan, both Muslims serving in the U.S. Army. Just as you celebrated your Muslim son’s sacrifice, there are others who could give testimony to their loss due to those Muslim soldiers — and I use lower case reference to them (soldiers) because they dishonored the oath and were traitors to our Code of Honor. Your son was not, but that had nothing to do with him being a Muslim: he was an American Soldier.
So, Mr. Khan, since you had such an immense stage, what should you have addressed? You should have taken the time to explain how humbled and thankful you are to live in America. You should have mentioned how honored your son was and the pride you felt knowing he was serving your adopted country. You should have explained to America, and the world, what killed your son…the ideology of Islamism, Islamic fascism.
You could have told all of us why it needed to be defeated and that we need a commander in chief who would not abandon Americans in combat, but ensure they were supported in order to defeat this scourge.
Mr. Khan, you could have taken these words spoken by a proven courageous and resilient leader, Sir Winston Churchill, who has a U.S. Naval vessel named after him, and expounded upon them:
“How dreadful are the curses which Mohammedanism lays on its votaries! Besides the fanatical frenzy, which is as dangerous in a man as hydrophobia in a dog, there is this fearful fatalistic apathy. The effects are apparent in many countries, improvident habits, slovenly systems of agriculture, sluggish methods of commerce, and insecurity of property exist wherever the followers of the Prophet rule or live. A degraded sensualism deprives this life of its grace and refinement, the next of its dignity and sanctity. The fact that in Mohammedan law every woman must belong to some man as his absolute property, either as a child, a wife, or a concubine, must delay the final extinction of slavery until the faith of Islam has ceased to be a great power among men. Individual Muslims may show splendid qualities, but the influence of the religion paralyses the social development of those who follow it. No stronger retrograde force exists in the world. Far from being moribund, Mohammedanism is a militant and proselytizing faith. It has already spread throughout Central Africa, raising fearless warriors at every step; and were it not that Christianity is sheltered in the strong arms of science, the science against which it had vainly struggled, the civilization of modern Europe might fall, as fell the civilization of ancient Rome.”
And now we can all understand why Barack Obama had Churchill’s bust removed from the Oval Office.
Those were the insightful, prescient, and relevant words of Sir Winston Churchill from the first edition of his book, The River War.
Mr. Khan, this is what you should have addressed; it would have been so very well received. You could have told the world and defined the enemy that killed your son…instead my assessment is that you will be remembered as a political pawn.
You could have taken the time to explain the words written by Thomas Jefferson and John Adams, dated March 28, 1786, to U.S. Minister of Foreign Affairs John Jay, reporting on their meeting with the Ambassador of Tripoli:
“We [Adams & Jefferson] took the liberty to make some enquiries concerning the ground of their pretensions to make war upon nations who had done them no injury, and observed that we considered all mankind as our friends who had done us no wrong, nor had given us any provocation. [Note they clarify “nations who have done them [i.e. Muslim Barbary States] no injury”] The Ambassador answered us that it was founded on the laws of their prophet [i.e. Mohammed]; that it was written in their Koran; that all nations who should not have acknowledged their authority were sinners; that it was their right and duty to make war upon them wherever they could be found, and to make slaves of all they could take as prisoners; and that every Mussulman [Muslims] who was slain in battle was sure to go to Paradise.”
Mr. Khan, you had a moment to speak on history and provide us clarity and truth from a Muslim man who lost his son, an American Soldier, to Islamists. You could have clarified the difference between your son and SGT Hasan Karim Akbar and Major Nidal Hasan. That sir, to me, was a missed opportunity.
Then again, maybe you had no intention of using the platform provided to you as a teachable moment…but rather a politically-influenced opportunity for gain.
You, Mr. Khan, had the chance to be the face and voice of a Muslim family that stood with the fundamental principles and values of liberty, freedom, and democracy upon which this Republic was founded — in which you have found a home.
You could have articulated how a 7th century savage and barbaric ideology inspired by a murderous warlord, psychopath, and, by modern day standards, a pedophile, was not a radical but the leader of a militant phase of Islam introduced after the 622 AD event referred to as Al Hijra.
Mr. Khan, I grieve for the loss of your son. However, I grieve even more that you used his sacrifice and loss as nothing more than a damn politicized stunt. May God forgive you for it.
Correct. This man West needs to be President.
Donald Trump did not kill MR.Khans son,radical islamists did,Hillary was directly responsible for the deaths of 4 Americans killed in Benghazi,then lied about it that night,and again when their caskets were returned and lied to the faces of the parents right in front of their caskets.
Donald Trump.wants to vet refugees who are being allowed into this country,refugees whom the terrorists claim they will embed more terrorists with them.
Hillary lied as recently as yesterday about her emails.
With all do respect to The Kahn family,your son is a hero and a patriot,I don’t know if Trump has read the Constitution or not,I have read parts of it but not all,but I do remember reading about a founding father who once commented that the Constitution is NOT a suicide pact,so I understand your pain,I can’t imagine the grief you must feel,please you are being exploited by a campaign of a candidate who has set the middle east on fire with her lying and manipulations.
Your venom is being directed in the wrong direction in my opinion.
With all that said I grieve for the loss of your son
ping and bfl
Too bad Trump didn’t talk to you Mr. WEST FIRST.
This is his problem,I agree with the destruction. Of Political correctness,but learning tact in situations such as these will go a long way towards victory.
Mr.Trump the entire establishment,Republican,Democrat,media,debate commission are against you,if you burp they will talk about you being a slob as Hillarys death machine marches onward.
Please use that smarts you always tell us about,attack Hillary not sympathetic individuals,it’s a no win situation.
Hillary is the enemy,you have more ammunition a candidate could ever wish for USE IT,KEEP BLASTING IT
After hearing Mr. Khan, I believe Mr. Khans son started his military career in order to enter American politics, where he could do as much damage as possible to our country.
ML/NJ
I add my disrespect to Mr Kahn as well. Sorry about your son but ESAD!
Too bad Trump didn’t talk to you Mr. WEST FIRST.
This is his problem,I agree with the destruction. Of Political correctness,but learning tact in situations such as these will go a long way towards victory.
Mr.Trump the entire establishment,Republican,Democrat,media,debate commission are against you,if you burp they will talk about you being a slob as Hillarys death machine marches onward.
Please use that smarts you always tell us about,attack Hillary not sympathetic individuals,it’s a no win situation.
Hillary is the enemy,you have more ammunition a candidate could ever wish for USE IT,KEEP BLASTING IT
Do you think you could send links that total how many US Soldiers were murdered by US muslime soldiers?
It would be great to have that info handy for the college federal government class I am teaching.
Thanks.
A Truly wonderful response.
Thankyou Col, West
Bookmark
The sly Muslim lawyer, Khan, is a pawn of the DNC and probably CAIR and the Muslim Brotherhood as well who went out on the stage in prime time using his dead son as a pawn to specifically attack Trump and his policies. Now Kahn and his allies are trying to hide their calumny under the racist and bigotry tent all the while precipitating this sh!tstorm in the first place.
The media, the DNC, Hillary, and CAIR/Muslim Brotherhood (but, I am repeating myself) are all in cahoots to smear Donald Trump and institute national policies (against the overwhelming will of the American People, by the way) which will permit the importation of millions more Muslims into this country which ultimately will cause immense bloodshed and destruction with their stated religious/political goal of instituting Sharia Law and making the USA a part of the Muslim Ummah.
They are a clear and present danger - all of them - and should be treated as such. At the least they deserve our scorn, not our sympathy. In reality they deserve much more as this is ultimately treason against the Constitution and our Republic.
Can you please elaborate?
Leni
Alinski rules for Kahn - identify, spotlight, ridicule.
Check out the story on the side bar about the guy being an agent for the Muslim Brotherhood.
Definitely! Great idea.
Mr. Kahn,
ESAD, you despicable bastard. You’re dishonoring your son’s service by your actions.
Disrespectfully, Bob
BTTT!
Disrespect BUMP!!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.