Posted on 05/24/2017 6:47:05 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
Big Government: President Trump's budget is taking its share of hits for supposedly indulging in fanciful accounting, unrealistic assumptions and proposing massive cuts to vital safety-net programs. How much of that is true? You decide.
Trump's budget plan proposes to balance the federal budget in 10 years and do so entirely through spending restraint. That alone is enough to raise the hackles of the Washington, D.C., swamp creatures. But critics have other complaints. The main ones:
It relies on unrealistic economic projections. Critics say Trump's budget numbers rest on a rosy scenario of future economic growth. The New York Times describes the economic forecast in its news story as "wildly optimistic."
Are they?
It's true that numbers in Trump's economic forecast are rosier than in other long-term forecasts. But that's because Trump expects his policies to increase economic growth.
Even so, Trump's forecast is hardly "wild." In fact, it assumes that annual GDP growth doesn't reach 3% until 2021, and never exceeds it after that. Over the next five years, Trump forecasts GDP growth to average a modest 2.8% a year.
Contrast these projections with the eight budgets Obama put out. In his first budget, Obama forecast GDP growth of 4% in 2011 and 4.6% in 2012. (Actual results: 1.6% and 2.2%). In all his budgets, the five-year GDP growth forecasts averaged 3.3%.
Yet somehow we don't recall budget experts gnashing their teeth about Obama's "wildly optimistic" growth forecasts.
Also, is it unrealistic to expect growth to top out at 3% and remain there for several years? In the past, average annual growth rates, including recessions, were higher than 3%.
MYTH: It guts the social safety net.
Trump's proposed spending cuts for entitlement programs have been described as "massive," "sweeping," and on the surface,
(Excerpt) Read more at investors.com ...
The best safety net is a job.
But Let’s talk about the term “CUTS” again.
Is it really a cut in overall spending, or is it simply a cut in spending INCREASE? If the latter, then there are NO CUTS.
Lets say, for the sake of argument, that medicaids budget is 100 billion. With a proposed increase of 5% which would put the new budget at 105,000,000,000. A proposal is given to cut the increase in half to 2.5%, which means the budget is increasing to 102,500,000,000. Democrats will claim that medicaid is being cut by 2.5 billion ( actually, to make it sound more dire, they’d say that it is being cut IN HALF ). When in reality its actually INCREASING by 2.5 billion.
They pull that out that lie every time someone tries to get spending under control and the Republicans allow them to do it. I wonder if Trump is as good a communications man as he claims to be....
"Look, Obama didn't really care about people who needed help. He didn't spend that much. Trump is much better -- that's why Trump is spending more money on the safety net than Obama ever did. Yes, adjusted for inflation. Trump is being more generous than Obama. That's not what you heard? Well, that's because the media lies to you. They said Trump was cutting spending on the safety net? No. It's the opposite. Trump is spending more than Obama. Just a fact. So, you might want to watch out when you believe everything the media tells you."
And the best motivation to get a job is no safety net.
What are you? Some kind of greedy capitalist? I'll bet you're a white male. Check your privilege! /S
Geez...I felt dirty and stupid just typing that!
If factual Trump continues the status quo
Interesting info. As usual, the media and Dems characterize a slower rate of INCREASE as a “cut.” Also, they casually accepted Obama’s much more optimistic GDP estimates (which did not even come close to the reality), while calling Trump’s more modest projections “wildly optimistic.”
And that means unserviceable debt piled upon unserviceable debt ... and that's the problem. If this is the best we can get even with TRUMP ... we're screwed.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.