[papertyger]

BTW, we are well familiar with the tactic of making a claim, then offering an undifferentiated “phone book” instead of a falsifiable argument.

If you can’t give a falsifiable summary, you are simply engaging in hearsay.

[BroJoeK]

papertyger: "BTW, we are well familiar with the tactic of making a claim, then offering an undifferentiated “phone book” instead of a falsifiable argument.
If you can’t give a falsifiable summary, you are simply engaging in hearsay."

So, I take it you favor the type of scientific exactitude practiced by other posters here, this one, for example:

editor-surveyor post #30: "Pathetic pulp fiction, and nothing more."

Now there is a real scientific argument for you, in the same class as E=MC² for it's brilliance & brevity, right?

</sarc>