9-0 spanking with four Communists chiming in. How can the 2nd Circus Court even bother to show up to work after that rebuke. They are a sad sack of $hit.
The case was important, though, for establishing a precedent:
“The Supreme Court took the unusual step of letting China present arguments even though it is not an official party in the case, a privilege typically reserved for the U.S. Justice Department.”