Posted on 08/18/2018 7:16:27 AM PDT by Kaslin
Is anyone really surprised by New York governor Andrew Cuomo saying, “We’re not going to make America great again. It was never that great.” The Left has been saying that, if not quite so bluntly, for decades. The only difference is that many more Americans now hold that view, including a disconcerting number of putative “conservatives.”
Dani Lever, a spokeswoman for Governor Cuomo, added that President Donald Trump’s Bull Moose patriotism “ignores the pain so many endured and that we suffered from slavery, discrimination, segregation, sexism and marginalized women’s contributions.”
Yes, we’ve heard that before too, but the crescendo of hysteria is reaching fever pitch. The Left now asserts that Robert E. Lee’s soldiers in gray were proto-Nazis; that Ulysses S. Grant’s soldiers in blue were genocidal Indian-killers; that America’s women still struggle against a colonial, patriarchal legacy of plantation owners in powdered wigs who kept their wives in comfortable confinement and their slaves as exploitable chattel; and that President Trump, far from being “a very stable genius,” which should be pretty obvious to everyone by now, is actually a moronic, unstable, but very clever agent of Vladimir Putin who quotes Mussolini in his sleep.
When it comes to American history (and sometimes Trump) how often have we seen putative “conservatives” falling over themselves to agree with the Left: furling Confederate flags and toppling Confederate statues as embarrassments; conceding that, yes, men like George Armstrong Custer were arrogant, bigoted, idiots from whose sins we should repent; and accepting a redefinition, never before known in human history, not just of marriage but of what it means to be a (now indefinable) man or a woman.
Such “conservatives” wish to conserve nothing save, maybe, capitalism.
But if you surrender your history, you surrender the future, and there is no reason why a nation founded in oppression, as the Left would have us believe America was, should survive, no reason why America’s constitution or its economic system should be respected, no reason why America should not be remade into something else through socialism.
In the 1970s, after the first eruption of the New Left’s historical revisionism and its cultural revolution, America’s retreat from Vietnam, and the malaise of stagflation, a narrative of inevitable American decline set in, accepted by the Left and mourned by the right. Writing in the 1970s, Robert Nisbet reflected that “it would be difficult to find a single decade in the history of Western culture when as much calculated onslaught against culture and convention passed into print, into music, into art, and onto the American screen” as during the decade of the 1960s.
The irony, speaking as one who grew up in the 1960s, is that those days seem like a wholesome paradise of Bonanza and Leave It to Beaver and the good-humored ribbing of celebrities by Johnny Carson on The Tonight Show compared to the hate-spewing, reeducation-camp propaganda of today’s entertainment-media complex that would have us believe that The Dukes of Hazard emerged from the pages of Der Stürmer, that The Honeymooners assisted in enforcing sexist, hetero-normative oppression, and that westerns featuring hardworking cowpokes like The Virginian “privileged” the stories of white, male rugged individualists against the need for an all-encompassing welfare state.
We are, obviously, in a much worse place today. The “silent majority” that saved us with the election of Ronald Reagan is now a minority, and Ronald Reagan’s restorative optimism seems out of place. Donald Trump’s belligerent reassertion of American nationalism against the commissars of political correctness who dominate nearly every institution in our society seems not only necessary but as heroic as Horatius at the Bridge.
As Churchill once called on his fellow Britons to fight the Nazi enemy “on the seas and oceans…in the air…on the landing grounds…in the fields and in the streets” so too do we need to fight for America’s heritage, its history, its heroic past in print, on the air, and on the screen—and this we have lamentably failed to do.
Immigrants who come to America today have no mystic chords of memory to bind them to our common culture. If we do not weave these imaginative chords, their view of America will be ideological—and dictated by the Left. If we do not weave them for young people, they will be severed from the past and willing to believe Leftist lies.
Our efforts don’t need to be—in fact, they should not be—po-faced. We need to recapture an unaffected, affectionate, generous understanding of our past—the sort of patriotism that used to be our common inheritance and the image we projected to the world.
Cuomo tweeted that Trump’s making America great again “would not be great at all. We will not go back to discrimination, segregation, sexism, isolationism, racism or the KKK.” But that’s not how the French thought of us in World War I. It’s not how Winston Churchill thought of Franklin Roosevelt and the United States in World War II. It’s not how the suppressed people of Eastern Europe thought of us during the Cold War. But it’s what the Left would have us think about ourselves.
If they succeed, and they are already well on their way, our future will not be that of a shining city upon a hill, but of a gulag where we are led in endless incantations of the words of Governor Cuomo.
Who is this guy??? He’s great; he says everything that I loathe about libs and conservatives who hate our history and only see it through a “presentism” lens.
Think Nikki Haley.
This article says it all.
You’re absolutely right. Sadly.
We could end up with wishy washy compromisers like Haley all over like the years when no one could tell any difference between the GOP and Dems. We’re not far from that today but thanks to Newt and Trump we have a few non-Lindsay Graham and Mitch McConnel types. Not a lot.
H.W. Crocker III is the author of the bestselling Robert E. Lee on Leadership, Executive Editor of Regnery Publishing, and a former speechwriter for the Governor of California.
Educated in England and California, his journalism has been widely published. He has also written a history of the United States military, Don’t Tread on Me; a history of the Catholic Church, Triumph; and the prize-winning comic novel The Old Limey.
He lives on the site of a former Confederate encampment near the battlefields of Northern Virginia.
I like the article, but he is wrong about Custer. He had it comin’, too bad the troops under his command had to suffer.
Huomo is a POS. He shot his juvenile divisive mouth off, then cowardly had to walk it back
A village in Venezuela is missing it’s idiot.
Yeah that’s where he belongs
Newt gets half credit because he often veers towards agreement with the democRATs.
America won’t be truly great until there are no more pricks like Huomo.
Thanks so much for the info! As a long-time admirer of RE Lee, I’ve had to put up with quite a bit of sh*t from freepers here who think the war ended last month.
If you're an inhabitant of Planet Earth and have any freedom then you can thank the United States of America for them.
I don’t watch TV news so I missed Newt cuddling up to the Dems. Disappointing. He should have bought a Teddy bear like Hogg.
Thanks so much for the ping. This is a moving and powerfully-written piece.
Maybe he should not have believed his own press releases. Or he should have listened to Jim Bridger.
But his foolish end does not take away from his other flashes of genius.
First in the Cuomo series. (Photoshop and text courtesy of FReeper poconopundit).
If those slaves hadn’t been sold to slaveholders by their fellow Africans, their ancestors today would running from cheetahs in Africa and living in mud huts.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.