[BroJoeK]

ml/nj: " 'Muddled or wrong,' according to Coyne and Orr "

Well, "muddled"? sure, since Darwin knew nothing of genetics, much less DNA, so it was only a vaguely defined concept 150+ years ago.

But it was remarkably correct: 1) descent with modifications plus 2) natural selection = 3) evolution.

[ml/nj]

You left out "wrong."

You also failed to address the chromosome problem I raised; your feeble reference to Adam and Eve notwithstanding.

See this old post of mine.

ML/NJ