The problem with libertarianism is that those who believe in its principles think man a perfect moral creature, who is capable of perfect rational thought, and will always choose the correct moral path.
IOW, the Libertarian does not recognize the consequence of Original Sin - that Man is a fallen creature.
The Libertarian philosophy may be distilled to is: “Do as ye please, for ye are gods.” Libertarianism is nothing more than a rehashing of the lies told to Eve in the Garden of Eden. It is satanic Utopian bullsh*t, in plain English.
While not wanting to go that deep into the religious aspects, I cannot disagree with you. If you talk to RedStateRocker, who told me, “GFY”, Libertarians think that everyone will just respect each others space, privacy, whatever. If that were the case, then the police would never get a noise complaint at 2am for the loud party next door. They would never get called to a dispute over a parking space or who trees are encroaching on someone else’s property. Things like Small Claims Court would become extinct, because everyone would respect one another so much, that there’d be no evil in the world.
Basically, there’d be no need for law enforcement, in any form.
You and I both know, that isn’t the case. There is plenty of evil in the world. You and I could live next to each and never have, issue #1. One crappy neighbor across the street can ruin the whole block. For some, it’s in their genetic makeup to be bad.