I’ve met a number of A-10 pilots who worked with her. I have never met one with anything good to say about her. And that was BEFORE she retired...
You are well informed on the McSally specifics - my wife saw her once on the goggle box and said 'she's no fighter pilot' and I [politely] inquired -'how can you tell?' and the boss said -'look at her skinny neck'. As in, reefing the airplane all day long over a decade and you will not be a pencil neck in your dotage. McSally is a fraud.