Judge decrees international human trafficking legal when wealthy sodomites buy babies from the poor.
Our laws have been replaced with judge’s feelings and emotions. At least when the issue involves liberals.
Any similar argument by conservatives would have been rejected.
Lots of freepers think this person is now eligible to run for President, sadly.
Natural born citizen means born here of citizen parents.
Born a citizen as suggested by Hamilton was rejected as not restrictive enough as it would allow those with divided citizenship, loyalties and allegiances to get into the Oval Office.
The founders wanted only those who were SOLELY Americans to be eligible for President.
ANYONE born with more than ONE nationality is NOT a natural born citizen.
An Asian judge, ruling that a child born in Canada to an Israeli woman and a man from God knows where is an American by birth. WTF, can we get more ridiculous?
This will be used as a precedent for animal rights, human clones and human-animal hybrids.
Eeriely similar to the Obama citizenship question, as his polygamous father was NEVER a U.S. citizen, just as the child’s mother in this case.
This case ignores Minor v. Happersett, which defined natural born citizen as issue from parents (plural) who are both citizens.
There is no such thing as “surrogate mother.” “Mother” does not need any qualifier. It’s “mother,” or non-mother.
Same way for “trans woman.” “Woman” does not need a qualifier. It’s “woman” or non-woman.
So a couple adopted a baby born in Canada. The way I interpreted the law is if a child is born in another country, that baby is born with the citizenship of that country. However, say the parents or birth mother was in that country on US gov’t assignment, then the baby is given US citizenship at birth. (Sometimes dual citizenship too).
But, I’m not seeing how this baby meets that criteria.
“The State Department determined that Kessem Kiviti isn’t a U.S. citizen because Adiel, the only parent with a biological connection to her, hadn’t lived in the U.S. long enough to meet a five-year residency requirement under a provision of the Immigration and Nationality Act, according to the couple’s lawsuit. But the five-year requirement is not meant to be applied to the children of married U.S. citizens, the couple’s lawyers maintained.
Adiel moved to the U.S. in May 2015 and became a U.S. citizen in January 2019. Roee has lived in the U.S. since 1982 and became a U.S. citizen in 2001.”
Damn, here is another twisted, bad decision by an Obama appointed Judge, Theodore Chuang. Obama did his best in selecting the bottom of the barrel to ruin decent courts. These flaky decisions are almost universally Obama appointees. Ocasionally, we get a Clinton appointee with a bad decision but not like with Obama appointees.
Total bs, but the state department likely won’t appeal allowing this crap to stand...
Hi.
Judge:. The 14th Amendment says what I say it says.
Didn’t Mark Levin write a book about judicial tyranny?
5.56mm
Agree with your revised headline.
I have to say that when I read the headline, I was far more concerned about the kid being raised by homosexuals than I was by the citizenship issue. Interesting what we choose to focus on. Both are serious and important issues.