No, in historical Presidential rankings he’ll be looked at as a peer of Franklin Pierce.
Cut Pierce some slack. He and his wife got to watch their young son get crushed to death en route to D.C. in a railroad accident. The wife lost her mind with grief and he spent the next 4 years in a drunken fog. More pitiable than incompetent. Shrub has no excuse for his incompetence, short of being the actual idiot the left called him out to be.