Posted on 12/08/2021 9:41:20 PM PST by SeekAndFind
A federal judge is siding with Project Veritas over its request for an independent party to review the cellphones the FBI seized from the group's founder James O'Keefe.
On Wednesday, District Court Judge Analisa Torres from the Southern District of New York is ordering a "special master" to be appointed to oversee the review of O'Keefe's devices, citing "potential First Amendment concerns."
"The Court recognizes, as other courts in this district have concluded, that ‘the Southern District prosecutors have integrity and decency,' and the filter team alone could conduct the review ‘with utmost integrity,’" Torres wrote. "However, the Court determines that the appointment of a special master is warranted here because ‘it is important that the procedure adopted… not only be fair but also appear to be fair.’ … In light of the potential First Amendment concerns that may be implicated by the review of the materials seized from Petitioners, the Court finds that the appointment of a special master will ‘help to protect the public’s confidence in the administration of justice.'"
"The appointment of a Special Master over the objections of the Department of Justice is further evidence of Government overreach in their heavy-handed violation of the First Amendment and journalistic privilege during the investigation of the purported theft of a diary belonging to the daughter of the President," a representative for Project Veritas told Fox News in a statement.
"Project Veritas appreciates the ruling but continues to insist that the Government show the public why they conducted these raids and return legally privileged material immediately," the representative added.
The judge previously ordered the Department of Justice to halt its review of O'Keefe's phones pending Project Veritas' request for a special master.
(Excerpt) Read more at foxnews.com ...
That’s good, I guess. But anyone else suspect that the contents of the phones have already been copied off, and given to whomever needed to see them?
SDNY, integrity and decency.
One of these things is not like the others.
Of course they have. And there will be no penalty for those responsible.
Yeah, that was my take on it, too.
Great - now that the feds have made copies of all the files, so to examine secretly at their leisure. The law no longer exists in this country. It dies long ago. FBI = Biden’s Secret Police. They are all above the law. Might as well be a “star chamber.”
bookmark
IIRC the judge issuing this ruling was appointed by Obama, and the special reviewer was appointed by Clinton. So, there’s a good chance both are corrupt.
Oh, I have no doubt they’ve done that. But what it DOES do is put a curb on what information they find out can be used in any prosecution. For instance, the Special Master determines that contact XYZ in the phones (and all information connected with it such as texts, emails, etc.) is protected 1st Amendment data, the FBI can’t dredge XYZ-derived data to use for prosecution.
OR, it means that the FBI cannot create new incriminating ‘evidence’ and install it on the phone and then use it to prosecute. THIS! to me is the more likely scenario because I fully believe the FBI manufactures fake evidence regularly for use against those they believe don’t comply with their deep state doctrine.
Any "review" now will be Kabuki theater. All of the contacts, emails, and texts are already in several databases and distributed to all of the "right" people at the FIB.
All this does is prevent any information on the phone from being used in a court of law. But it will be used for investigative purposes, even for investigations that are politically motivated.
“The Court recognizes, as other courts in this district have concluded, that ‘the Southern District prosecutors have integrity and decency,’
This is government persecution. Charge them with bs and suck all the money out of them through endless court proceedings.
I think it’s more an issue that they wanted to provide the Times(?) with info regarding their lawsuit.
Oh, I’m sure that the FBI sorely wanted to get out as much hurtful information as the could gleaned from the phones but I in no way believe that the completely corrupt FBI wouldn’t stoop to actually planting evidence on the phones. There’s no question about it in my mind. January 6...
People need to use ‘tails’ os.
I think Glenn Greenwald said he uses it for secure research.
‘tails’ just runs from a thumbdrive, and the user tucks files away on a different system.
Phones are the FBI’s easiest way to invade someone.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.