Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: far sider
Are you really a physicist?

There are no solar neutrinos. Several major experiments have been conducted to find them, but they are not there.

Something tells me I'm rising to bait by saying this, but you're wrong. Solar neutrinos most certainly do exist. They were first measured in the 1960's.

There used to be a solar neutrino deficit problem: the experiments only measured one third of the number of neutrinos that were predicted by the Solar Standard Model. Last summer, the reason for this was discovered by researchers at the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory: neutrinos have mass, and they change "flavor" as they travel. There are three flavors of neutrino, but the former experiments only measured one type, electron neutrinos. This wasn't expected to be a problem, because the sun only produces electron neutrinos, but as since they change flavor in transit, that assumption was wrong. SNO measures all three types of neutrino (electron, muon, and tau). When you add them all up, you get exactly what was predicted by the Solar Standard Model.

14 posted on 07/18/2002 7:04:14 AM PDT by Physicist
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies ]


To: Physicist
I must haved missed the lecture about "strange" xenon and ordinary xenon. What's the straight poop on that?
16 posted on 07/18/2002 7:21:25 AM PDT by balrog666
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies ]

To: Physicist
Are you really a physicist?There are no solar neutrinos. Several major experiments have been conducted to find them, but they are not there.

Something tells me I'm rising to bait by saying this, but you're wrong. Solar neutrinos most certainly do exist. They were first measured in the 1960's.

There used to be a solar neutrino deficit problem: the experiments only measured one third of the number of neutrinos that were predicted by the Solar Standard Model. Last summer, the reason for this was discovered by researchers at the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory: neutrinos have mass, and they change "flavor" as they travel. There are three flavors of neutrino, but the former experiments only measured one type, electron neutrinos. This wasn't expected to be a problem, because the sun only produces electron neutrinos, but as since they change flavor in transit, that assumption was wrong. SNO measures all three types of neutrino (electron, muon, and tau). When you add them all up, you get exactly what was predicted by the Solar Standard Model.

Yes, I was baiting you. Sorry. Yes, I know you are a physicist. (I've seen your posts before.) And yes, I am refering to the solar neutrino problem. Your argument (actually Sudbury's) that the neutrino problem has been solved is so bogus. Are you really satisfied to say that "Well, since we can't detect enough solar neutrinos, they must be turning into an undectable kind of neutrino. Since we can't detect them they must be there. Problem solved." I'm surprised that as a physicist you would accept this circular reasoning. When you can prove that neutrinos can change "flavor", and when they figure out a way to detect muon and tau neutrinos, and actually detect them, then I'll believe the sun's heat is really nuclear, and that the sun could be 4.5 million years old.

P.S. Did they really detect one-third of the amount predicted? I have read it was around 1%, which may be cosmic rather than solar, and that's why they came up with the flavor change theory in the first place. My understanding of the theory is that essentially all of the neutrinos change to the undectable forms before they reach earth, and they eventually change back into electron neutrinos because they oscilate among the three different flavors. Earth "just happens" to fall in the nondetectable zone. I'm just asking because you're a physicist. Thanks.

18 posted on 07/18/2002 7:46:17 AM PDT by far sider
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies ]

To: Physicist
neutrinos have mass, and they change "flavor" as they travel. There are three flavors of neutrino,

This really irritates me. Now, when I get home with the wrong flavor of neutrino, I can no longer blame the store for selling me the wrong neutrinos. Sigh.

I have to brush up on my particle physics... There has been some important work done lately and I'm not keeping track of it. 'Course, it's difficult enough to keep track of work in my sub-field, let alone a totally unrelated but way cool field...

34 posted on 07/18/2002 9:13:54 AM PDT by Chemist_Geek
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies ]

To: Physicist
I understand that the Sun puts out a SNU of neutrinos.
43 posted on 07/18/2002 2:42:02 PM PDT by Poohbah
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson