Actually, CDs are superior to LPs frequency response-wise, and superior in the realm of dymanic range.
Why do LPs sound better to you and myself?
Because of being used to its sound, and THD. A digitally recorded and mastered album would not sound too good on vinyl, I would imagine.
Why do LPs sound better to you and myself?
I don't doubt you are right about that. Could it be that with digital sampling there is less information to carry around so any frequency changes happen quicker, at the expense of resonance? I don't know, maybe it's like you suggested. Anyway, there are quite a few musicians who have said that they can tell the difference between CDs and LPs and that the latter has better sound quality...for whatever reason.