>> If you don’t believe you have a soul...then you think you are made up of only protoplasm. It’s a fact, not an accusation and no amount of discussion on this thread will make a bit of difference to you if you believe that all of Calvin is in that grave. If you believe in a soul...what’s the problem? <<
That’s exactly what I inferred from what you said. Hence, when you called him protoplasm, I also inferred you thought he’d say he didn’t have a soul. But even an agnostic could accuse you of reductionism. Even if an agnostic doesn’t believe he has a soul, he may believe that his protoplasm is arranged in a manner which makes it more significant than other protoplasm.