Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

[Catholic Caucus] Archbishop Chaput and Cardinal Cupich clash over Youth Synod
LifeSite News ^ | September 28, 2018 | Stephen Kokx

Posted on 09/28/2018 8:47:31 PM PDT by ebb tide

PHILADELPHIA, Pennsylvania, September 28, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) — Philadelphia Archbishop Charles Chaput rejected criticism leveled against him by pro-gay Cardinal Blase Cupich over an anonymous critique of the Youth Synod working document that Chaput published on First Things last week.

In a letter released today, Cardinal Cupich alleges that the anonymous critique “falsifies the truth,” displays “condescension toward the issues raised by the bishops’ conferences,” and represents a “woeful lack of understanding of magisterial teaching.”

Chaput maintains the critique did none of those things and insists he supports it.

In brief, the critique alleges that the Instrumentum Laboris being used for the Synod is heavily naturalistic, too focused on the Church’s need to “listen” rather than teach, presents a distorted definition of vocation, and relays an impoverished understanding of Christian joy.

Chaput says the critique was written by a “respected” North American theologian and that he published it after having received “scores of emails and letters” from lay Catholics and clergy concerned about the synod’s intent.

He also published it after having concluded the critique was “substantive enough to warrant much wider consideration and discussion as bishop-delegates prepare to engage the synod’s theme.”

Although currently mired in a scandal involving the removal of a Chicago priest from his parish for burning a LGBT “rainbow pride flag,” Cardinal Cupich found time to respond to Archbishop Chaput in the form of a letter to First Things, the website that originally published the critique on September 21.

Cupich devoted much of his letter to criticizing the anonymity of the author.

“The increasing use of anonymous criticism in American society does not necessarily contribute to healthy public discourse, but in fact can erode it,” Cupich warned.

“It also raises fundamental questions about why First Things would publish such an anonymous critique.”

But Chaput defended the theologian’s anonymity by stating:

“As to the anonymous nature of the critique: I certainly agree with the cardinal that unnamed sources can be regrettable. So is the toxic environment in many of our academic communities that makes them necessary."

Cupich claims that the critique doesn’t take into account the fullness of the working document’s text. He also accuses it of “false reporting” and “partial truths.”

Implying that the critique lacked charity, Cupich says that what is needed now is “a concern for the church” that is “animated by a love for truth” and “the spirit of synodality.”

In his response, Chaput dismissed Cupich’s accusation that the critique wasn’t motivated by love.

“In fact the critique I selected is among the most charitable I've received from scholars,” Chaput writes.

Noting how he was “grateful” for Cupich’s “useful comments,” Chaput nonetheless said he does not disagree with the critique of the Instrumentum.

Still, Chaput continued, a synod’s working document is “a work in progress, open to discussion and adjustment by the Synod Fathers. I'm sure we can count on that process in the upcoming synod conversation.”

TOPICS: Apologetics; Catholic; Moral Issues
KEYWORDS: chaput; cupich; francischurch; homos; yutes
Catholic Caucus
1 posted on 09/28/2018 8:47:31 PM PDT by ebb tide
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Al Hitan; Biggirl; Bigg Red; Coleus; DuncanWaring; ebb tide; Fedora; heterosupremacist; ...


2 posted on 09/28/2018 8:48:13 PM PDT by ebb tide (We have a rogue curia in Rome.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: ebb tide
The Church listen? Yes, to determine the needs of its members, but it must teach the Truth, not some relativistic concept of the moment.

"Dia shábháil ar fad anseo!"

3 posted on 09/28/2018 8:54:33 PM PDT by ConorMacNessa (FMF Corpsman - Lima 3/5 RVN 1969 - St. Michael the Archangel defend us in Battle!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: ebb tide; Impy

I’m jealous of Philadelphia and San Fransico for having REAL Catholic Cardinals. The poser in Chicago is a disgrace.

4 posted on 09/28/2018 10:26:53 PM PDT by BillyBoy (States rights is NOT a suicide pact.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: ebb tide

Chaput is a great man. I met him at a Kateri conference in Spokane. We stayed at the same hotel and shared a bottle of wine with friends. I knew there he should be Pope

5 posted on 09/29/2018 5:33:54 AM PDT by FatherofFive (Islam is EVIL and needs to be eradicated)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: ebb tide
Cdl. Cupich has lost all credibility!

AB Chaput's credibility is growing exponentially.

6 posted on 09/29/2018 6:36:50 AM PDT by G Larry (There is no great virtue in bargaining with the Devil)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: BillyBoy
San Fran has a good one? The gays there must really hate him.
7 posted on 09/29/2018 3:07:48 PM PDT by Impy (I have no virtue to signal)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 4 | View Replies]

To: Impy
>> San Fran has a good one? The gays there must really hate him. <<

Yeah it's Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone. BEFORE he went to San Francisco, he was known for being extremely OUTSPOKEN against the gaystapo crowd, and he hasn't budged an inch since they put him in the homo capital of the USA. Pope Benedict XVI literally put Archbishop Cordileone in the belly of the beast. (I'm reminded of when Republicans appointed the first black U.S. Senator to Jefferson Davis' old Senate seat in Mississippi)

On a side note, Archbishop Cordileone is good friends with my pastor and frequently is a guest on his radio show. They served in seminary together and share very similar ideological views.

8 posted on 09/29/2018 8:08:39 PM PDT by BillyBoy (States rights is NOT a suicide pact.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson