Posted on 10/31/2018 10:36:21 AM PDT by NRx
It is that time of year again when Orthodox and some other Christian writers attempt to warn people about the evils of Halloween. They assert—and I have done no less in my much younger days—that Halloween is a pagan holiday, and thus everyone who participates in its celebrations by default participates in the ancient Gaelic harvest festival called Samhain (“summer’s end”). As I grew older I saw that the people who dress up as princesses and Marvel super heroes have about as much to do with devil worship (for this is often the claim) as people who send each other Christmas cards or Easter candy have to do with worshiping Jesus Christ. This is all that I will say about it, and it may be a topic for another time. For myself, I still do not see any need to celebrate Halloween any more than I do the Chinese New Year, the Parinirvana Day, Eid-al-Adha, or Yom Kippur. But I am no longer interested in writing pseudo-pious articles linking my neighbors’ children to devil worshipers for merely dressing up in costumes any more than I am interested in condemning Russian Orthodox Christians for making (and partaking of!) pancakes on Maslenista, since pancakes are an ancient pagan symbol of the cult of the Sun (round, yellow, hot—reminds of anything?).
However, the grinches of Halloween (of whom I am chief) just might see the death of it after all. And no, it is not our fiery blog posts and inspirational sermons that are killing the evil practice of carving pumpkins and exchanging miniature candy bars. No, the butcher of Halloween is the modern phenomenon of super-sensitivity and hyper-offendedness. It is insensitive to dress up as a princess because this is a class misappropriation and may offend real princesses. Likewise, one should not dress up as a prince or a knight, unless the same is in fact a prince or a knight. No more Count Dracula costumes—they may be insensitive towards ethnic Transylvanians and persons bearing the noble title of count. Definitely, no Cowboys or Indians—for very obvious reasons. The Little Mermaid costume may offend persons with sirenomelia. A pirate costume is insensitive to people who have been victims of real pirates. (And it may also offend Somali-Americans due to the Western stereotyping of Somali pirates in the MSM.) Certainly, no more skeletons, zombies, or any other costume with reference to injury or death, because they may trigger traumatic experiences in some people. And no, no more children dressed as teddy bears, cats, or any other animal—speciesism and misappropriation! No more black capes. Period. They offend Orthodox clergy. Obviously, nothing sexy due to the abomination of objectification! No more nurses, nuns, witches, firemen, or clowns. I should not have to go on; the pious reader will understand the principle by which any costume is inappropriate unless worn by the very actual person it pretends to portray.
Halloween decorations are no less harmful in our culture. Heads carved out of pumpkins risk offending people who are sensitive to all of the recent beheadings committed by Islamic terrorists. Fake hanging corpses are unacceptable because they trigger the historical trauma of lynching. Spiders and spider webs are offensive to people with arachnophobia; and the fake RIP tombstones are insensitive to those who recently lost their loved ones. No more scarecrows in the yard, because they may scare people who are scared of scarecrows. There simply is not a single piece of Halloween decoration that is not insensitive or outright offensive to someone!
It is very possible that in our lifetime, the greeting “Happy Halloween!” will finally be replaced with the neutral “Happy holidays!” and everyone will walk around dressed strictly as themselves, exchanging carrot and celery sticks. (Candies are offensive to people without dental insurance and may be a conspiracy of the dental lobby.) Perhaps then, Orthodox bloggers with stop writing about the horrors of Halloween and focus instead on the memory of the Evangelist Luke or Saint Joseph of Volotsk, whose memory we celebrate on October 31 (those on the new calendar will have a pick of several of the Seventy Disciples.)
Happy Reformation Day!
Reclaim All Hallows’ Eve [Ecumenical]
Halloween and Catholicism
Traditional Catholic Sacrifice of the Holy Latin Mass on Halloween Night
Faith Facts: All Hallows' Eve
Be Not Afraid: The Surprisingly Holy Origins of Halloween
Hallowe'en (with facts and recipes)
How Halloween Can Be Redeemed (from Catholic Update)
History of Halloween
Bishops’ Halloween Advice: Dress Children Up as Saints, Not Witches
Halloween (CNA Video)
All Hallows' Eve
Celebrating 'All Hallows Eve' and the 'Feast of All Saints' in a Pre-Christian West
Halloween Prayers: Prayers and Collects for All Hallows Eve
Holiday Hysteria (a Christian defense of Halloween)
Hallowe'en - Eve of All Saints - Suggestions for Reclaiming this Christian Feast
Nowhere does he address the fact that it is a pagan holiday.
I expected him to answer the question and he just didn’t.
This is a hoot. I went to Halloween potluck last weekend dressed in jeans, a long blond wing and bright red cowgirl hat. The outfit comes with a toy gun, but I knew that would be offensive so left it at home.
Still, I managed to DEEPLY OFFEND the stupid liberals there. Red hats suggest Trump and MAGA and all that.
These were grown women, otherwise fairly intelligent.
So beware.
Yay Halloween!
Bring on the happy children and candy!
After the porch light goes out we’re gonna watch House Of Wax with Vincent Price, scarrryy!
Yay Halloween!
Ok, as for me I hate Halloween and the people who fill thier front yards with displays of death and mayhem need to be watched.
It's not cultural appropriation, I'm Liz Warren.
And watch heads explode.
Um. That young squaw is far more qualified for public office than Liz. :)
By the way,thank you for posting this good article.
Priests and ministers who complain about Halloween are just as bad as Orthodox Rabbis who refuse to sanction having Thanksgiving dinner. They are American cultural holidays. They ought to lighten up and participate or clam up and get out of the way.
I just want to hear “Monster Mash” non-stop for a few days, ok?
LMAO. You’ve made my day.
“Monster Mash” followed by “Thriller” on a non-stop rotation.
Contrary to popular views, Halloween actually has Christian origins. The Druids did not start it; that alleged link is false.
In fact, Halloween is explicitly Christian in origin by mocking evil and Satan.
Christmas is also a pagan holiday, but I intend to celebrate both.
Christmas displaced Saturnalia, Easter displaced Passover, St Valentine’s day replaced Lupercalia, yadda, yadda, yadda.
If you eliminate all the Christian holidays the date for which was chose deliberately as a substitute for some pagan festival, there’d be nothing left to celebrate except Income Tax Day.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.