[jdege]

Generally speaking, the standard for peer review in the medical journals is only a weak shadow of that for the physical sciences.

[SeekAndFind]

Generally speaking, the standard for peer review in the medical journals is only a weak shadow of that for the physical sciences.

I am also very curious as to how the Nobel Peace Prize committee actually peer reviewed Al Gore's powerpoints before giving him the Nobel Prize.

Did they actually consult scientists ( including those who disagree ) to determine if his alarmism has any factual basis ?

[A Strict Constructionist]

“Generally speaking, the standard for peer review in the medical journals is only a weak shadow of that for the physical sciences.”

If the paper comes from certain institutions or researchers it is accepted, how dare we disagree with one of the annointed. Check out where the NIH fraud comes from. The more liberal the institution the more likely the fraud in my opinion.