The REASON I am intrigued by Mensur’s paper is that THE COMET SHOULD NOT BE IN IT!
This Astroblog guy has more credentials than a Physicist from the European Royal Society? The Astroblog debunker assumes that the only factor here is a comet in the alignments described, which does make the paper nonsense, I agree. So, if we assume that there is ONLY a comet at the locations of Elenin, then Astroblog is right and the paper is junk.
Mensur Omerbashich leaves out any statements about the Comet Elenin’s mass, or why it is incredulous that it is in his paper.
If there is JUST a comet, the mass is like a feather compared to anything else in the paper. And is also much less than the asteroid NEOs that the biologist lists as conspicuously missing.
I feel that the asteroids are missing from the paper for the same reason that the comet SHOULD be missing. They are not massive enough to matter.
Here is the big question.
Why is the comet in Mensur’s paper?
What isn’t said, is WHY the alignments of Elenin appear to have a coincidence with the large earthquakes, just as other massive planetary alignments do?
The implication is that the comet isn’t a comet, but something else more massive. They have shown pictures of it, so I believe there is a comet there.
Could there be something else, of large mass involved with the trajectory of the comet? This is unknown to us.
The comet doesn’t belong in Mensur’s paper, so WHY does Cornell University allow him to continue with updating it, and hosting it for him? They, even more than the biologist in Australia, should be laughing him right off their website, shouldn’t they?
Why did NASA redirect the STEREO B spacecraft to look at the comet? Did they take any OTHER pictures they did NOT publish? Could those pictures have been of a massive object somewhere else?
I don’t know, and I bet neither do all the raving lunatics on this forum.
If someone does know about some massive object which could explain WHY the comet is in Mensur’s paper, and they are just shouting me down, I guess I understand. We wouldn’t want to panic people. That could make it difficult to make orderly preparations, right?
They don't. That is the rebuttal that guy made. And it flew right over your head.
If someone does know about some massive object which could explain WHY the comet is in Mensur’s paper, and they are just shouting me down, I guess I understand. We wouldn’t want to panic people. That could make it difficult to make orderly preparations, right?
So at the end of the day, you are just another internet conspiracy loon.
Oh, and we are not ‘shouting you down’ because of some conspiracy. We are simply pointing out that you are an idiot.
Did your physics education cover the fallacy of asking someone to prove a negative?
The more I read this post, the bigger the idiot you become. Do you REALLY think a planet-sized object could have entered the inner solar system with NO ONE NOTICING changes to the orbits of the other planets? That is how they discovered Neptune - Uranus had some oddities in its orbit and calculations led an observer directly to where Neptune was calculated to be.
Now tell us how EVERY space agency, EVERY college and EVERY amateur astronomer has failed to notice shifts in the orbits of the inner planets.
This should be good. Must be some all-powerful outfit to be able to shut down all such information - except for internet claims with no data to back up such.