Yes, ice was warmer back then.
This is ALL BULL$HIT because of one very important reason- SIGNIFICANT FIGURES
If you measure with a yardstick, it is impossiblke to quote measurment size in FEET or INCHES.
You can say 1.5 yards (approx.) but you can not accurately say 1.5005 yards, or 1 yard, 1 ft, 6.5 inches. That is too many significant figures.
The resolution is not there to make such fine measurements
Similarly, If you only have TREE RINGS to go by, there is no way possible to say that temperatues are 0.5 degrees warmer now.