I would be inclined to let doctors, families and a judge decide who does or who does not need to be locked up
Therein lies the problem with me, families I would trust. Doctors and judges not so much.
There is too much corruption and to many agendas being pushed these days.
Again, what would the criteria be? How do you know which person is going to snap? Do we incarcerate them because some one decide they MIGHT commit a crime?
It's a difficult dilemma to be sure, but I'm not ready to let bureaucrats decide peoples fates based on their whims and public pressures.
JMHO.