Please freepmail me if you want on/off this list
Posted on 05/15/2006 4:08:09 PM PDT by NYer
"Catholics Are Victims of an Offense"
ROME, MAY 15, 2006 (Zenit.org).- The press office of the Opus Dei Prelature sent this statement to ZENIT on Friday in response to comments by the director of the soon-to-be-released film "The Da Vinci Code."
* * *
On Thursday the Italian press published interviews with Ron Howard, director of "The Da Vinci Code" film. In statements attributed to him, Howard said that "to deny the right to see the film is a fascist act," and also "to tell someone not to go see the film is an act of militancy and militancy generates hatred and violence." The Opus Dei is mentioned several times in these interviews. The phrases seem to refer to recent statements by Church authorities.
I would ask Ron Howard to keep calm and express himself with respect.
It is not wise to lose sight of the reality of the situation: This film is offensive to Christians. Howard represents the aggressor, and Catholics are victims of an offense. The one offended cannot have his last right taken away, which is to express his point of view. It is not the statements of ecclesiastics or the respectful request of Opus Dei -- to include a notice at the beginning of the film that it is a work of fiction -- which generates violence. It is rather the odious, false and unjust portrayals that fuel hatred.
In his statements, Howard also repeats that it is simply a film, an invented story, and that it must not be taken too seriously. But it is not possible to deny the importance of the movies and literature. Fiction influences our way of seeing the world, especially among young people. It is not right not to take it seriously. Artistic creativity certainly needs a climate of freedom, but freedom cannot be separated from responsibility.
Imagine a film that says that Sony was behind the attacks on the Twin Towers, which it promoted because it wanted to destabilize the United States. Or a novel that reveals that Sony paid the gunman who shot the Pope in St. Peter's Square in 1981, because it was opposed to the Holy Father's moral leadership. They are only invented stories. I imagine that Sony, a respectable and serious company, would not be happy to see itself portrayed in this way on the screens, and that it would not be satisfied with an answer such as "Don't worry, it's only fiction, it mustn't be taken too seriously, freedom of expression is sacred."
In any case, those who have taken part in the film's project have no reason to be concerned. Christians will not react with hatred and violence, but with respect and charity, without insults or threats. They can continue to calculate tranquilly the money they will make on the film, because the freedom of financial profit seems to be in fact the only sacred freedom, the only one exempt from all responsibility. They will probably make a lot of money, but they are paying a high price by deteriorating their prestige and reputation.
I hope the controversy of these months will not be sterile but serve to reflect on the relative character of financial profit when high values are involved; on the importance of fiction; on responsibility, which always supports and protects freedom.
[The statement added:]
The plan of Opus Dei's Communication Office in regard to this case may be found on the Web page www.opusdei.org, which explains in detail its position over these months.
[From] Manuel Sánchez Hurtado, in charge of relations with the international press, at the Opus Dei's press office in Rome
I'm glad they're speaking out. A shame slander/libel laws don't apply to organizations, though I suppose it's best they don't.
Opie has gotten his head full of liberal Hollywierd mush.
"to tell someone not to go see the film is an act of militancy and militancy generates hatred and violence."
Wow, now the Catholic Church cant tell people not to go see a film without generating hatred and violence.? pleaseeeeeeeee
Nice
Opie's the one who is generating hatred and violence.
The entire key to this controversy right there! That is what you are defending, when you defend this trash.
Hey Opie... I'm NOT going to see your putrid film! Are you going to hate me....hit me??
oooh I'm so afraid!!
OK - got my flame retardant suit on - here goes.
Do you think those hundreds of thousands of people, in the history of the Church, who did dare to voice their opinions and became victims - dead - who had their "last right taken away," for their "offense" are looking down and saying: "hmmm - good thing marshmallowing people at the stake isn't allowed now."
I would like to have seen this level of condemnation over their pedophile priests - whom they have known about and protected for generations and only took some action after being forced too. (There were many "victims of an offense" - little victims - for decades and decades...and they were not protected. Only the perpetrators and the Church were protected, with the perps simply shifted to other, unsuspecting parishes.)
Two things: "People who live in glass houses..." and
"As ye have done until the least of these, my children...
Nice strawman you raise there...
Hollywood hates Christians, ESPECIALLY Catholics.
And Ron Howard is one amazingly arrogant little hypocrite is he not?
IMHO Opus Dei is right on, except they should include all Christians. All Christians are offended and insulted by blasphemy, slander, and greed. I am disgusted with Sony and the debased hollywood crowd.
Hmmmm Joan of Arc was burned at the stake by Catholics?..... The Salem witch trials...Catholics? 2000 years of history?
You, the guy in the flame retardant suit... take 5 minutes and list all the Catholic atrocities.
Don't include me in your grouping. I'm not offended by the movie as I know it is a F..I..C..T..I..O..N..A..L piece of work. I may even go see it. I sort of always liked those movies about 'hidden treasures'. I saw National Treasure and do you know to this day, I realize there's not a map on the back of the Declaration of Independence?
'to deny the right to see the film is a fascist act," and also "to tell someone not to go see the film is an act of militancy and militancy generates hatred and violence."
Did anyone in Hollywood have the courage to say that about the right to see the Mohammed cartoons? No??
Any of the networks show the cartoons in defiance of a fascist attitude? No??
Anyone in Hollywood say that about Mel Gibson's film??
No??
Anybody in Hollywood care about free speech if there isn't money involved? No??
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.