American Idol 2009--Live Thread II

americanidol.com ^ | 3-17-09

[silent_jonny]

.

For Ladyinred

[Timeout]

Good grief.
Simon must have his boxers on upside down or something.
That was boooooring.

[silent_jonny]

Matt Giraud

His song is "Funny Valentine"

Boring!

Even Jamie Foxx was at a loss (at first) for anything to say.

Randy: Probably one of the hardest songs ever. Pitchy. Didn't all come together for me.

Kara: I can appreciate all the runs ... but I didn't feel you were emotionally connected to it.

Paula: I love what you did with the song. I felt the emotional connection. We got to hear a different side of Matt. Excellent job.

Simon: Matt, I'm going to have to disagree ... with Randy. For me, that was the only believable, authentic song I've heard tonight. I thought you were absolutely brilliant.

Meh.

[TonyWpi]

Oh crap!

Simon may have just bailed Matt out. That means Kris goes home.

[LA Woman3]

Simon agreed with us!!~

[Shortstop7]

Simon is smoking something tonight. ;)

[MagUSNRET]

I dont think he did a bad job...I merely think this is the week he (and his mole) get cut.

[skateman]

Cowell is playing psychology games with us voters. Matt is gonna win, so don’t bother to vote for him?

[Majie Purple]

Matt’s The Mole!:)

[Raebie]

lololol at that pic!

[Fawn]

I agree with the others...he’s trying to skew the results to something.....

[Jrabbit]

Simon and me are oil and water, tonight.

GO MAVS!

[hugorand]

I agree, Simon is being a contrarian tonight for whatever reason.

[bert]

yep

[Fawn]

HAhaha.....the picture....

[slugbug]

Actually at this point in the competition, there shouldn’t be many horrid performances-they all sing well IMO.

[Majie Purple]

I guess so.

[maggief]

WTF?

Simon playin’ the voting.

Kick the Matt Hatter to the curb.

Allison just kicked it! (Love, LOVE the shoes!)

[silent_jonny]

Thanks, Peggy :)

[retrokitten]

Yes, you are right.

[Fawn]

Shoes? Sounds like a Paula remark....:)