Skip to comments.Is OJ as good a source of vitamin D as supplements?
Posted on 05/08/2010 4:18:11 PM PDT by decimon
A glass of orange juice may not only help the vitamin pill go down. A new study suggests that fortified varieties can also help the body's vitamin D levels go up - just as effectively as the supplement itself.
The finding could bring a welcome addition to a very short list of sources for vitamin D, which is thought to help fend off an array of health problems including brittle bones, diabetes, and cancer.
"A lot of people don't drink milk," which has been fortified with vitamin D since the 1930s, "but they do drink OJ in the morning," the study's study author, Dr. Michael Holick, of the Boston University School of Medicine, told Reuters Health.
Simply adding a vitamin to a food does not guarantee its absorption in the body. In fact, since vitamin D dissolves in fat but not water, there was concern that only fatty foods such as milk could be used.
But preliminary research several years ago by Holick and his team suggested that orange juice - not known for its fat content -- might be an effective way to deliver the vitamin. This prompted Minute Maid and Tropicana to begin adding it, along with calcium, to some of their products. (A division of Coca-Cola, which owns Minute Maid, funded Holick's study.)
(Excerpt) Read more at news.yahoo.com ...
I don’t know what you would get from squeezing him, does he have any money left?
Best source of Vitamin D is sunshine. It’s free and fun to get the full dose.
Diabetics do not drink any orange juice. It is never good for you. Eat oranges but never drink orange juice.
Vitamin D absorption needs some sort of fat, so OJ may not work.
Supplement-wise gelcaps are pretty good, the capsules with powder don’t work so well.
“Diabetics do not drink any orange juice. It is never good for you.”
I’m diabetic and I never heard that!
“Is OJ as good a source of vitamin D as supplements?”
No, he’s still looking forthe “real killers”
course, it could be the new bourbon I have been drinking in the evening ;-)
If people want supplements to their diet they should just buy them instead of having people sneak them in as additives to various foods. What happens if your over-consumption of a certain food gives you an overdose of some added vitamins or minerals?
An 8 ounce glass of milk provides 30% of you daily requirements of calcium, 25% of you vitamin D and Phosphorus requirements, 10% of you vitamin A requirements, and 4% of your vitiman C requirements. Plus, it provides body-building protein.
Why the put vitamin D and calcium in OJ, I’ll never understand.
Don’t drink OJ. OJ will kill you.
The sun is the best source, if you can tolerate it.
Can’t get it in the winter time in most of the country. Certainly not in N. California this past winter.
It will make your head pop off.
Well come to Arizona, you can get it 364 1/2 days a year. If you don’t mind associating with a bunch of “racists” *wink*
Me too. I drink it, and of course we with this medical challenge do. All within the carbohydrates we plan into our day. It’s a great way to raise a low blood sugar too (as you well know).
Hey does this peeve you a bit as it does myself,,,when I see that really fat guy, is it Walter Brimley(?) you know that old fat guy, on ads for a diabetic supply home delivery company? Now he’s a great guy I am sure, but to pick a morbidly obese guy as a spokesman and have him say “and be sure to check your blood sugar...” irks me. I say “Hey how ‘bout you lose a hundred pounds before you preach to me, Chubby?”. I don’t know it just bugs me.
I also pass on the altered OJ. It’s amazing how many things they’ll add to a perfectly good natural food. The choice of “no pulp, lots of pulp, normal pulp” seems a bit silly too. Add that to the other choices and it’s just too much. Just give me my OJ already!
OJ is a killer. Avoid OJ at all cost.
Drinking a glass of OJ is like eating 4 to 5 oranges for us.
Next to impossible to do for about half the year in Minnesota.
And before you ask, I used to live in Phoenix. I *prefer* the tundra. :-)
I see it as food tampering. Calcium isn't even natural to oranges (as far as I know). So why the h--- are they adding calcium to orange juice? And what about no pulp, some pulp, lotsa pulp? It's ridiculous.
And since I'm here, what's with sugar-free Snapple? I can't even find a bottle of regular Snapple with sugar anymore. It's been replaced by Diet in both the small and large sizes. The non-sugar freaks ruin it for the rest of us!
Adding the URL for the abstract was nice.
I don’t know about vitamin D, but OJ cuts to the bone.
Where do you get it if you don't own a cow?
Orange Juice first is excellent for you. The potassium from OJ is terrific, also you get magnesium but less than pottasium, don’t fear the natural sugar, it’s God’s sugar. If you want to get Vitamin D get out in the Sun. Direct sunlight, unlight what you have been taught is “GOOD” for you. It was putting on sunblock that block UVB’s (which are used to create Vitamin D) and let in UVA’s (which cause skin cancer) are what caused all the skin cancer. Or put another way, the medical community really screwed and caused untold damage by giving the worse advice they could to all of America.
If you really want to supplement I suggest Carlson’s fish oil Vitamin D, they have 400 or 2000IU and I take them sometimes. But I try to get 1 hour of direct sunglight on my skin with no sunblock.
They do make sunblocks now, in case most newer ones do (with the last two years only) that block both UVB’s and UVA’s.
Fine if you live in Florida, but not so practical in the North.
Which one is that? I just discovered Jim Beam Black.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.