Skip to comments.Taliban: 1 U.S. sailor dead, other captured
Posted on 07/25/2010 7:52:29 AM PDT by kbennkc
KABUL, Afghanistan (AP) -- The Taliban have offered to exchange the body of a U.S. Navy sailor they said was killed in an ambush two days ago in exchange for insurgent prisoners, an Afghan official said Sunday.
U.S. and NATO officials confirmed that two American Navy personnel went missing Friday in the eastern province of Logar after an armored sport utility vehicle was seen driving into a Taliban-held area.
In a telephone interview Sunday with the Associated Press, Taliban spokesman Zabiullah Mujahid said the pair drove into an area under insurgent control, prompting a brief gunfight in which one American was killed and the other was captured. He said both were taken to a "safe area" and "are in the hands of the Taliban."
(Excerpt) Read more at washingtontimes.com ...
It used to be called mission creep or wag the dog. Now with the Navy there maybe we are still trying to find a new route to India. In short FUBAR.
This debacle calls to mind those arguments of a few years ago about "you can't say you support the troops if you don't support the mission". Some of us argued that this is pure nonsense, sometimes one has to oppose the mission in order to support the troops. This is one of those times.
Turn the Northern provinces in to glass, let god sort them out.
You are absolutely right. We need to wipe out every living thing in those regions and be done with it. There is absolutely no chance of living peacefully with the people in that region. If it were not for air travel I would say leave them alone, but they chose to bring there sick demented perverted cult to us. allah is a joke and all who believe in this fantasy need to be wiped off of the earth. muslims are like retarded children with guns and bombs, wake the hell up America and make islam a capital crime.
In this order...
Don’t forget Damascus and Pyongyang, those mother effers.
Someone posted yesterday (I’m not sure this is true, but it could be checked) that there have been more combat deaths under 18 months of Obama than under 8 years of Bush, but these deaths are simply not getting any press play. Whoever knows where to look for the stats could probably verify this.
Just from what I can see, however, Afghanistan has gone way up.
God be with that captured Sailor. To be taken alive was about the worst thing one could imagine over there.
Huh? Are you seriously proposing that we kill babies and old ladies on such a Hitlerian scale? Instead of doing that, here's a new concept for you: bring the troops back from this quagmire.
That would be to employ the tactics of Genghis Khan, the only foreign leader who had success in Afghanistan
Or we could withdraw and periodically spray their poppy fields with Agent Orange (or any other herbicide) from the air. De-fund the terrorists and let them eat rocks.
Were we attacked by smackheads?
No, we were attacked by people who financed themselves (at least partially) by raising poppies for opium production. Dead smack-head infidels just count for bonus points.
No, but by eliminating the funding source for the enemy (and their supporters in Pakistan) we might turn them back into starving stone-age thug wannabes...which makes them impotent, irrelevant, and possibly easier to identify for killing.
This debacle calls to mind those arguments of a few years ago about “you can’t say you support the troops if you don’t support the mission”. Some of us argued that this is pure nonsense, sometimes one has to oppose the mission in order to support the troops. This is one of those times.
Exactly what is the mission?
Does the President know?
Do the Generals know?
Do the troops know?
Do the citizens of America know?
If the stories are true about the mineral deposits they found, I bet the Chinese would sign up for 160 free acres.
I hope the stories are true and it leads to development and prosperity for the Afghans. I fear the stories are a cynical hoax to convince some there is something in that hell hole worth fight for, played by the same rats who claimed President Bush was waging war for oil.
Any word on the identity of the sailors? Or their rank and rates?
From the details of what happened, I'm guessing they weren't corpsmen or special warfare. They were probably Individual Augmentee (IA). There's a lot of this these days. IA sailors are ones that for whichever bit of bad luck came their way, they were selected to go to Iraq or, most commonly these days, Afghanistan. Prior to deployment, they're sent off to Ft. Bliss or some other INCONUS training installation and given a very abbreviated lesson in soldiering. Then it's off to Afghanistan were they provide behind the lines administrative support that frees up the Army and Marines for combat duties.
As far as I know, no IA sailors have been KIA yet. Navy combat deaths have tended to be limited to corpsman and special warfare but I could be wrong. This might be a first.
The IA’s usually train at Ft. Lewis, WA depending on what their mission “in-theater” is going to be.
The Chinese, if we aren’t careful...
We had one in our command train at Ft. Bliss and another at Ft. Bragg. Looks like there are many installations that provide IA training according to the Navy IA website.
We have a Navy Det here at Lewis who works with us when we have Navy units coming through (mostly Gitmo and Medical teams for Centcom)...we give them hell for that snazzy blue camo uni they wear ;)
You’re right though, others do go through Bliss and Benning I think.
Don't laugh! The new NWU allows us to hide in the ocean! LOL!
Of course, I'll never complain about any uniform that I can wear straight from the dryer.
IOW...bring them home now.
It should be remembered that the Soviets killed a million Afghans. Look where that got 'em.
Track them back to their hide outs and exterminate with extreme prejudice.
I’m torn...as an ‘old-timer’ I think we look like duffle bags (sea bags to you), but it sure is nice not starching uni’s, and polishing boots!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.