American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[RummyChick]

This time Ryan is the Ragin Contagin...

Next week...it will be like the auditions...
what’s with Randy’s four checks???

[Cudjo]

and those stupid judges grave him an O

[Raebie]

Can’t stand Joshua. He would be great on Glee or Smash though...

[silent_jonny]

Joshua Ledet
(1st Song)

His Queen song is "Crazy Little Thing Called Love". Cruise-shippy. Bordering on annoying.

Randy: That was unbelievable. Vocals--four checks. Performance--four checks. Character, charisma--four checks. You remind me of Sam Cooke. This is like a Wilson Pickett young dude in the making.

J-Lo: I love all the singers in the competition, but is it bad to say that Joshua is my favorite part of the show? A suprise every time. So good.

Steven: A classic style. Freddy would looooove that.

[freedumb2003]

>>This time Ryan is the Ragin Contagin..<<

Nothing PISSES me off more than “heroes” who come to the office when they are ill.

I was sick last week and worked form the hotel.

[al_c]

So did not like that one. Love the song ... that arrangement ruined it.

[MagUSNRET]

The Gravelly quality to Elise’s voice is suited to this tune...she is doing OK...the gal is a Rocker..she needs to stick to that genre, I think...kinda like a sober Janis Joplin LOL ;-)

[freedumb2003]

Elise did well on this one — not out of the building but about as good as Jessica.

[kjam22]

yeah.. that was the best of the night for me so far

[RummyChick]

interesting set up where the judges give critiques without the Ragin Contagin..maybe it is in the back puking

[al_c]

interesting set up where the judges give critiques without the Ragin Contagin..maybe it is in the back puking

Critiques? There hasn't been any critiques since Simon left the show.

[freedumb2003]

>>interesting set up where the judges give critiques without the Ragin Contagin<<

Are we 100% sure the judges don’t prerecord their comments?

[silent_jonny]

Elise Testone
(1st Song)

Her Queen song is "I Want It All." Here we go! Unlike Joshua and Jessica, Elise's voice suits Queen perfectly. Good song choice too.

Steven: You found your stride with a just-right song. I really enjoyed that. That was over the top.

J-Lo: You're in your element. You look great and sound great.

Randy: What a night so far. That was unbelievable. Brilliant. That was one of your best performances to date.

[retrokitten]

We’d have absolutely no way to know it.

[MagUSNRET]

Good Grief...JLO the “actress” cant even fake it! It is so freakin obvious that she is reading a script before she gives any critique...it is almost funny!
Watch her after the next singer...she is always refering to her notes!

[silent_jonny]

Hi, Bug! :)

Another One Bites the Dust....I’m thinking that should be the goodbye song at the end of each show! ;)

LOL!

[Shelayne]

OK, that Google Chrome commercial was kinda cute. I am ready with the mute for that stupid Nike commercial.

[RummyChick]

I find it hard to believe Steven is reading from a script. His stuff is so nonsensical sometimes..

[silent_jonny]

Elise talks too much.

[retrokitten]

Yes.