American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[retrokitten]

Hilarious!

[peggybac]

I missed it - who just was on screen talking to Elise?

[retrokitten]

Jason Segal

[retrokitten]

What is she wearing? It would be not half bad if it didn’t have that weird tulle bustle/tumor on her hip.

[kjam22]

ELise is clicking tonight.... I like it. I hope they don’t compare it to the original to hard. I like this version...

[MagUSNRET]

Fredericks of Hollywood must be having a sale on their “Not quite a Diva” wear

[slugbug]

I didn’t care for Elise tonight but of course the judges loved her...

[freedumb2003]

She really nailed this song. I have never heard it before so this is my “original” version. Elise did great on this

Dress: from the Morticia Adams Collection.

[Netizen]

Yeah, fugly meets boudoir.

[retrokitten]

It was okay. Not horrible, but not great.

I think Skylar and Joshua were the best of the night and Hollie is in danger of going home.

[silent_jonny]

Elise Testone

She gets a surprise greeting from actor Jason Segal, via video. (she and her mom saw his movie on Sunday, says she's a huge fan of his)

She ends the show with “You and I” by Lady Gaga. Not bad for a Gaga song. Starts off playing the piano, then grabs a mic and moves around the stage. Idol pulls no punches with this production, they fill the stage with guitar players and a horn section. Really selling this.

But Elise doesn't need all the window dressing. She carries this very well on her own.

Randy: America, Elise is back! Perfect time for that vocal. You needed a moment and I think you got it tonight!

J-Lo: You did exactly what you wanted to do. Let go but remained in control. No one sings like you. You're our closer!

Steven: You turned it into genius. Laid a beautiful vocal over it.

Seacrest: Elise is back!

I think they want Elise to stay, LOL

[kjam22]

Yeah.. I like Elise’s voice. She has character in it big time.

[silent_jonny]

Even after the re-cap of tonight's performances, they still have 4 minutes of dead air to fill.

Seacrest fills this with a lot of blathering from the judges.

Seacrest: Who would you most be worried about?

The judges don't answer. Just urge America to vote for their favorites.

Bet the save will be used tomorrow.

[38special]

I’m afraid if Hollie isn’t voted off tomorrow then the judges will use the save.

[slugbug]

I agree-I think Hollie is going home...I don’t think the judges will use the save on her...but they would on anyone else

[Netizen]

They have to use it by what, top 5?

[silent_jonny]

Hello :) Glad you stopped by.

[Netizen]

here’s a bit of a surprise.

http://www.dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp?week=7&sort=TD&type=score&season=11

[Captain Beyond]

Hi Jonny just wanted to stop by and say Hi. It has been awhile but have been busy with projects. I thought Elise did a good job with this and she has a great tone. She has got to pick a music style and stick with it if she stays.

I think her problem with her being in the bottom 3 so much is she having a hard time with finding a fan base because she is all over the place when it comes to picking songs. One week it is R&B, the next week it is a ballad, then rock, then pop, etc. She has got to pick a groove like Cookie did and make them all pop/rockers regradless of the music genres, or James Durbin going with metal versions, or like McCreedy did making them all country. IMHO if she had started out with Power Ballad/Rock style she would be ok. She did great on “Whole Lotta Love” and could have swung the rocker vote.

Anyway Haley Reinhart did “You And I” last year and did a pretty good job with it also. Haley went more with the chorus after the break and was much more bluesier with her version. I don't think Lady GaGa did Haley any favors doing it as a live feed the next night on the results show because everyone would be comparing Haley's 2 minute version to the GaGa’s full version. The main thing I remember about Haley was reading in a trade sheet that year was that her AI/Yourtube performances were pulling in like a gazillion views in a couple of weeks.

I am still tripping that she beat out James Durbin for top 3. (Paging Chris Daughtry pick up the white courtesy phone please) But hey at least Judas Priest made an AI appearance and that was so cool. Never in a million years did I think I would see them on AI,

I like Colton and Phillip but they are really going to have to step it up if they want to stay in this. I wish Erika could have made it further she has a real nice voice also.

[silent_jonny]

Question: Am I the only one cocking my head like the RCA Victor dog, trying to understand the lyrics Jessica is attempting to stutter?

Nope. I didn't care that song at all.