OK . . . .
Therefore, your explanation for what Shadowstrike experienced is
exactly what?
I don’t have an explanation. I’m simply saying that an order to “stay with your family” doesn’t make sense — therefore, it can’t be used to determine whether the message was for November 2008, or some future November 1st — it wouldn’t make sense in either case.
Logically, it is hard to draw any absolute conclusions. It is much easier to do comparative logic, because it doesn’t require any underlying value judgments, just the ability to understand like things.