Posted on 05/22/2007 1:42:02 PM PDT by bahblahbah
Cannes - A semi-documentary about a group of US men who had sex with horses has taken the title as the most shocking movie at the Cannes film festival.
But while Zoo has drawn big, curious crowds at its screenings, the real unsettling quality about the movie is its approach: it depicts the men in a sympathetic light, one that tries to push the viewers to understanding their sexual perversion.
The documentary - in which actors recreate non-explicit scenes under audio interviews with some of the men involved - centres on a true-life incident.
In July 2005, a 45-year-old man died of internal bleeding after being anally penetrated by an Arabian stallion during a bestiality weekend in the US state of Washington.
The victim, a Boeing engineer working on top-secret defence projects named Kenneth Pinyan, suffered a perforated colon.
The ensuing investigation led police - and eventually much of the national media - to the farm where the interaction took place, outing the other members of the group.
Independent filmmaker Robinson Devor shies away from prurient imagery, instead enveloping the story in rich photography that gives it a dreamlike beauty overwhelming the sordidness of the subject matter.
Absence of judgement
"In this film, there were things with much more importance to us than the sex aspect," he told journalists after a screening in the sidebar Directors' Fortnight section.
He said the absence of judgement was a deliberate choice, one reinforced after he watched some of the actual videos the men had taken of their horse sessions - footage that doesn't make it into the film, apart from the barest of glimpses at one point.
"They showed us the videos not to show us pornography, but to show an animal that wanted to be with them," Devor said, though he added that he kept some scepticism about the taped acts.
"We don't know what the conditioning was (for the horses)."
Many reviews have been favourable to the approach taken by Devor and his team.
"They've crafted a subdued, mysterious and intensely beautiful film that presents bestiality not for the purpose of titillation?but as a way of investigating the subjective nature of morality," the movie trade magazine Variety wrote.
'Mammal to mammal love'
The men heard in the film are remarkably honest about their motivations. One of them argues "mammal to mammal" love should not be seen as wrong.
Another firmly rejects the tag "bad person" his employer lays upon him before he is sacked. They all say the horses were willing participants.
Indeed, the only judgement seemingly expressed in the documentary is not on the matter in the stable at all. It is in fleeting radio references to US President George W Bush's "war on terror" and the presumed complicity-for-profit of big companies such as Boeing.
Even the cast ended up feeling compassion for the men depicted in Zoo.
John Paulsen, who played Pinyan, said he believed the engineer had been on a self-destructive streak linked to his defence work, a divorce and injuries from a motorcycle accident.
"Here's a man whose greatest loves in his life were so secret, so private," and who abruptly had "these great secrets in his life made so public by dying in such a public and humiliating way," he said.
But Paulsen himself acknowledged the black humour surrounding the incident, and now the film, saying that "in a way, it's a classic Western, except here it's the horse riding the man."
He added with a smile: "I call this role my 15 inches of fame."
Countdown to thread death in....
WILBURRRRR!!!
Nay means Nay, mister!!!
Those that call evil good and good evil....
It would be an interesting to see which reviewers who gave this movie a positive review also gave “Sicko” a positive review.
the more deranged, perverted, sick, indecent, evil, the more applauded by the critics. notice how the good films never get their approval. it has to be some sick device spring from the darkest corners of the human soul or they don’t bother.
Going so far as to try and blame "the military-industrial complex" for this guy's mental illness.
Has anyone really seen what a horse’s (you know what) looks like - how big it is? I have and I have to wonder who in their right mind would let a horse “penetrate” anything on their body? That’s just sick.
I can’t see where there would be anything “beautiful” about this kind of stuff... more like EVIL.
Beat me by 5 seconds!
How many defense projects do we have named Kenneth Pinyan?
“They all say the horses were willing participants.”
Well duh — stallions will breed a block of wood! That’s how they get the semen for artificial insemination.
Love? I don’t think so!
Dunno. Concrete-penetrating bunker-busters?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.