Posted on 06/21/2012 1:41:20 PM PDT by SeekAndFind
William Jefferson Clinton...Incubus.
“...We might now again be British colonists, but for Lincoln.”
It could have been sooner! Back in the 1840s the US and Canada almost went to war over the Oregon territories.
Great Britain attempted to get a treaty uniting Britain, Mexico, Canada and the new nation of TEXAS against the US.
Texas was so horrified at the proposal they immediately joined the US as a state, and Mexico ended up taking the brunt of the war as GB and Canada settled with the US over Oregon.
What you learn from thirty years of haunting libraries with real BOOKS!
There’s a French movie from 1919 that includes a scene with the dead of World War I rising and returning home to see if their sacrifice was honored.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J%27accuse_(1919_film)
Too late for poor Mary Suratt.....
More like a Seneca.
Mary was almost certainly quite guilty, though prosecutors might not have been able to get a conviction in a civilian court.
No they would not have. What chance did she even have, when she could not even testify in her own defense?
Yankee justice.
One more reason Lee & Johnson should have fought a guerilla war.
There were dozens of witnesses called by the defense in this case. What leads you to claim she was not allowed to testify in her own defense?
Read the record. There was also a recent movie on the subject. Any court that denies a defendants rights to testify in their own defense is a kangaroo court.
This is the 167th footnote in the Wiki entry for Mary Suratt.
Neither Mary Surratt nor any of the other defendants testified on their own behalf. Although some sources claim that they were prevented from doing so, this is incorrect. At the time, the federal government and 35 of the 36 states did not permit defendants in felony trials to testify on their own behalf. See the discussion in Boritt and Forness, p. 352-353.
If accurate, this would mean she wasn't allowed to testify, but not because this was a kangaroo court. She would not have been allowed yo so testify in almost any court at the time.
The rule appears to have been a hangover from common law, in which nobody was allowed to testify who had an interest in the outcome. Since most if not all felonies were originally capital crimes, the accused obviously had a pretty strong interest in the outcome.
The qualification of criminal defendants to give sworn evidence if they wished came last. The first statute was apparently that enacted by Maine in 1859 making defendants competent witnesses in prosecutions for a few crimes. Maine Acts 1859, c. 104. This was followed in Maine in 1864 by the enactment of a general competency statute for criminal defendants, the first such statute in the English-speaking world. The reform was largely the work of John Appleton of the Supreme Court of Maine, an American disciple of Bentham. Within 20 years most of the States now comprising the Union had followed Maine's lead. A federal statute to the same effect was adopted in 1878, 20 Stat. 30, 18 U.S.C. 3481. Before the end of the century every State except Georgia had abolished the disqualification. 6
http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=us&vol=365&invol=570
Her trial may indeed have been, probably was, a kangaroo court. But her not being allowed to testify did not prove it so unless every other criminal court in the nation outside Maine also qualified as such.
Nor is her having possibly had an unfair trial any evidence for her innocence.
Ok, I concede that part, but on what basis was her supposed guilt? She ran the boarding house. Most accounts that I have read of this trial didn’t deal with hard evidence. Like Dr. Samuel Mudd, who had the unfortunate bad luck to have set John Wilkes Booth’s broken leg.
This whole thing was revenge based.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.