Skip to comments.Secondhand Lions Original Ending
Posted on 01/13/2013 12:58:30 PM PST by Kartographer
I had no idea that there was an different ending for this movie! And as there are many FReepers who are fans of this movie I though you would enjoy it as much as I did!
No matter how you shake it...this is a four-star movie. I kinda wish they’d make it into a TV series.
Oh please no! They’d mess it up, make it politically correct...it just boggles the mind to think what they might do to it. Loved the movie BTW.
Ping for later viewing.
Didn’t he commit suicide in the movie or something?
I thought the DVD had a couple of alternate endings?
One of my favorite movies of all time.I like this ending.
Our disc has alternate endings, none of which are this one.
It also has some awesome deleted scenes.
Thanks for posting it.
Thank you for posting this; I didn’t know either, very interesting!
Not to worry, no pc nonsense in this ending, just an epilogue.
On the recommendation of a friend, I took my then 12-year-old-son and his buddies to see it. They - we - loved it. It's in my DVD collection now.
Thanks for posting this. What a great movie. I haven’t watched it in a while. Going to have to dig out the DVD.
Fantastic movie. I like the original ending better.
a great movie, indeed. self-pinging so i can download later.
Gosh, this movie was just on last week! I love this movie! I had no idea it had a different ending!
That is a good ending, I don’t remember seeing in the extras. I think someone put together some raw clips because some of the music was lifted from other movies. Music from the credits of “The Black Stallion” is in there.
Hun??? You got your movies mixed-up me thinks.
I don’t know I like the French Foreign Legion showing up and the 5 punks that Hub beat some sense into all those years before showing up as striaght-up men now.
That was just nine kinds of awesome. Thank you, Kart.
I thought they decided to go out in a suicide pact with the plane.
They crashed the plane, but they were just trying to do acrobatics flighing threw a open barn
"I'm Hub McCann. I fought in two World Wars and countless smaller ones on three continents. I led thousands of men into battle with everything from horses and swords to artillery and tanks. I've seen the headwaters of the Nile, and tribes of natives that no white man had ever seen before. I've won and lost a dozen fortunes, killed many men, and loved only one woman... with a passion a flea like you could never begin to understand!! That's who I am."
"Nice evening. Peaceful...."
bump for later viewing.
A great movie. Thanks, Kart.
I like the original ending better. Shorter and made the point.( “the real things worth believing in.”)
That was a great “little” movie.
That was great. Alhtough I like the one they chose, it’s nice to have options. One of my favorites..and Robert Duvall IS my favorite. He’s great in this movie...but as Gus McCrae, he is tops.
That character reminds me of a long passed friend/lover...right down to the mannerisms, hand gestures and the way he shakes his head. I couldn’t believe it when I first saw it....sigh.
I don’t know. That’s a little drawn out. I hate to say it, I don’t like either ending. What bugs me the most is the kid grew up to be Berkley Breathed... I mean, a cartoonist, but exhibited no such talent in the beginning. It just seems tacked on. If he had been a writer of adventure stories-—now that would have made sense.
Yeah man...they went out with their BOOTS ON!
LOL...The look on Hub’s face after that skeetshooter demo was priceless..
I would say a stable environment would bring out talents in such a boy.
But he should have exhibited SOME artistic talent or cartooning ability (as a kid) in the beginning to make this work for me. I’ve watched the movie again and I still saw no evidence of that. Wouldn’t the wild adventures the old guys told him made for pulp novels? That would make sense.
I guess I would re-edit the ending. I would combine the funeral with the helicopter arrival and the grandson of the Sheik.
I don’t see where such an ability could have easily be built in to the movie.
My family and I love this movie. It was recommended by a co-worker when we were discussing the lack of quality movies for preteen and young teen boys. She also suggested the movie “The Librarian” with Noah Wyle and we enjoyed that too.
Now that I’ve viewed the new ending, I would like to think both events happened. :)
MANHUNTER also had an alternate ending. I saw it years ago on Showtime and still have the tape of it somewhere.
The missing scene is after the bad guy gets killed the detective tracks down the NEXT family on the list to be killed. As he is at the door the husband comes running through the house with a .45 in hand and places himself between the detective and the wife.
The detective explains he wanted to make sure they were OK and then leaves. Cut to the scene at the pier.
Several movies have alternate endings.
Didn’t like this ending as much. Too long, drawn out, and he has to do the whole speech about believing lies before you are left with the idea the stories were true.
The real ending was short and too the point, and still left you with some possibility that all the old men had made up stories.
I think both endings removed all doubts that the old menss story were true. WHy else would the old Shiek fo the old Shiek’s grandson show up?
Love the film. I live 3 miles from where it was filmed.
Really? A small scene in the beginning, he’s sketching something and his mother tells him to stop, that it wouldn’t amount to anything...15 seconds. But, like I said, it would have made more sense if his great-uncles’ stories had inspired him to write adventure novels based on their adventures, but alas.... otherwise, I love 80% of this film.
That one was OK, but I kinda like the original ending better.
I saw this movie in 2005. I did not know there was an alternate ending.
Thanks. I like both endings.
That movie is the best. Thanks for reminding me about it. : )
My Dad was called away at 76 years and 6 months. That has been almost 10 years ago this month. To do all he said he did he could not have been a day short of 100. We were told what we passionately believed and listened to in total fascination as children and then when we became adults began to doubt as tall tales.
Over the years, we have learned it was all true. Dad never told a lie and we should have known better than to doubt him.
Hitchhiked across America when he was 13, truck driver, forest fire fighter, dozer operator, surveyor, logger, hiked across Panama, gold mining in the Klondike on a lark, sailor, fighter pilot and crashed a couple of airplanes, engineer, builder, endless travels... all true. His best story we witnessed... a fantastic Father who taught us so much. He may not have had much money but he never denied us his time or love... ever.
He taught us to pick principles worth dying for and to carry his name with honor because that is how it was brought to us.
This movie makes me feel so sad every time I see it. We had a concrete water tank just like that one at the farm. Dad rode his motorcycle until the week before he went to the hospital. I think he visited everybody in the county he knew and some he didn’t. An airplane would have been just better for thrills. He knew then he would die soon but he gave it his best for as long as he could!
I must be a real fool, I was waiting for the "helicopter arrival and the grandson of the Sheik" to arrive / appear.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.