Posted on 07/18/2021 1:51:51 PM PDT by Capt. Tom
A panel of judges of the U.S. Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals last night ruled in favor of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)’s position in its ongoing legal battle with the state of Florida over the agency’s right to impose COVID-19 regulations on the cruise ship industry.
Yesterday’s decision stays Federal District Judge Steven Merryday’s previously June 19 injunction order against the CDC, which would have prevented the public health agency from enforcing its Conditional Sail Order (CSO) in Florida. This would have rendered the comprehensive framework of regulations set out in the CSO, intended to steer the safe restart of cruise ship operations, mere recommendations for cruise lines to follow, rather than requirements.
USA Today reported that the panel’s two-to-one vote was handed down Saturday night only minutes before midnight—just before Florida’s injunction against the CDC was set to go into effect.
Florida’s Governor Ron DeSantis first filed a lawsuit against the CDC back in April over what he called the “unlawful” shutdown of the cruise sector amid COVID-19, arguing that the federal agency had overstepped its authority and angry at the prospect of losing state revenues generated by the multi-billion-dollar cruise industry as the summer season approached.
He also issued an executive order creating a law that prohibits Florida businesses, including cruise lines, from requesting evidence of vaccination from their customers. This forced multiple major cruise lines, which had originally announced that they would require all eligible passengers to be vaccinated prior to sailing when cruises restarted, to alter their rules for Florida departures.
That is, except for Norwegian Cruise Line, which declared that it would transfer its operations out of Florida if DeSantis persisted in his efforts to cripple the CDC’s Conditional Sail Order. Norwegian had actually filed court papers in support of the CDC’s rules, which were developed in close cooperation with major cruise lines. And, only days ago, Norwegian actually filed its own lawsuit against Florida to retake the right to require that eligible passengers be fully vaccinated when it resumes operations in August.
The CDC lodged its appeal against Merryday’s injunction against its framework for the safe restart of cruise operations on July 6, defending the CSO and saying, "It does not shut down the cruise industry but instead provides a sensible, flexible framework for reopening, based on the best available scientific evidence." It argued, “undisputed evidence shows that unregulated cruise ship operations would exacerbate the spread of COVID-19 and that the harm to the public that would result from such operations cannot be undone.”
The agency also warned against the potential dangers of DeSantis’ new law forbidding cruise lines to request proof of vaccination, explaining: “Cruise ships are uniquely situated to spread COVID-19, due in part to their close quarters for passengers and crew for prolonged periods, and stops at foreign ports that risk introducing new variants of Covid-19 into the U.S."
Well as we are used to by now, the saga continues. -Tom
I hope he appeals it...
Under what statutory authority.
Fine. Just let the floating Petri dish industry fail some more.
I’ve never once seriously consider going on a cruise ship
Would much rather spend that money on a fishing charter in the Keys and evenings at a nice tiki bar
That actually sounds so much better. The Keys are gorgeous.
I remember when I was a kid, cruises looked so glamorous (I blame Love Boat) and then I finally went on one and hated every freakin’ germ riddled trashy second of it.
. In our courts today the Judges not the Constitution rules. -Tom
Good now I don’t have to waste my time and money.
If you’re not interested in cruising, why respond to this post? Many of us love to cruise and we appreciate Capt. Tom posting the latest news.
Seriously, what is the name for the psychological problem that compels members of Free Republic to chime in with negative comments whenever there is a post about cruising?
Of course it will be appealed. This is so blatantly wrong. How can one stupid agency which never had the power given to them based on weak science regulate an entire industry?
The 11th circuit has been a corrupt court for some time now.
Infiltrated.
For the price of a cruise or two, I could buy another sailboat and have enjoyment for years.
Excellent! Stop in Marathon and say hi to my Cuban buddies...you will find them in all the bars lol.
You can buy a sailboat for ~$1,000? My wife and I sailed through the Panama Canal for $1,400. That won’t buy much of a sailboat. If you don’t like cruises, don’t ever go on another. But why state blatant falsehoods to make your case?
What makes you think you have to respond?
Under what statutory authority.
3 posted on 7/18/2021, 1:53:45 PM by Fledermaus
/\
\/
The stompy racist foot statute as usual.
Most of them are bartenders and patrons from the north
Met a nice couple in Key Largo that live in a town just 10 miles from me
Got hooked on Rum Runners down there
What does the CDC and the cruise lines propose to do with folks that have already had Covid and not have been vaccinated?
For Carnival they have to request an exemption and try to be part of the 5% unvaccinated ...The CDC doesnt regard them as immune...
If they can prove they were diagnosed and hospitalized with Covid and can prove it, they maybe OK, otherwise they would be treated as unvaccinated deplorables. - Tom
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.