Skip to comments.How to Lose Your Job in Talk Radio: Clear Channel gags an antiwar conservative Charles Goyette
Posted on 01/10/2004 4:49:11 PM PST by Destro
February 2, 2004 issue
Copyright © 2004 The American Conservative
How to Lose Your Job in Talk Radio
Clear Channel gags an antiwar conservative.
By Charles Goyette
Imagine these startling headlines with the nation at war in the Pacific six months after Dec. 7, 1941: No Signs of Japanese Involvement in Pearl Harbor Attack! Faulty Intelligence Cited; Wolfowitz: Mistakes Were Made.
Or how about an equally disconcerting World War II headline from the European theater: German Army Not Found in France, Poland, Admits President; Rumsfeld: Oops!, Powell Silent; Bring Em On, Says Defiant FDR.
It seems to me that when there is reason to go to war, it should be self-evident. The Secretary of State should not need to convince a skeptical world with satellite photos of a couple of Toyota pickups and a dumpster. And faced with a legitimate casus belli, it should not be hard to muster an actual constitutional declaration of war. Now in the absence of a meaningful Iraqi role in the 9/11 attack and the mysterious disappearance of those fearsome Weapons of Mass Destruction, there might be some psychic satisfaction to be had in saying, I told you so! But it sure isnt doing my career as a talk-show host any good.
The criterion of self-evidence was only one of dozens of objections I raised before the elective war in Iraq on my afternoon drive-time talk show on KFYI in Phoenix. Many of the other arguments are familiar to readers of The American Conservative.
But the case for war was a shape-shifter, skillfully morphing into a new rationale as quickly as the old one failed to withstand scrutiny. For a year before the war, I scrambled to keep up with the latest incarnations of the neocon case. Most were pitifully transparent and readily exposed. (Besides the aluminum tubes and the trailers that had Bush saying, Gotcha, does anyone remember those death-dealing drones? Never have third-world, wind-up, rubber-band, balsa-wood airplanes instilled so much fear in so many people.) Still, my management didnt like my being out of step with the presidents parade of national hysteria, and the war-fevered spectators didnt care to be told they were suffering illusions. So after three years, I was replaced on my primetime talk show by the Frick and Frack of Bushophiles, two giggling guys who think everything our tongue-tied president does is Most excellent, dude! I have been relegated to the later 710 p.m. slot, when most people, even in a congested commuting market like Phoenix, are already home watching TV.
Why did this happen? Why only a couple of months after my company picked up the option on my contract for another year in the fifth-largest city in the United States, did it suddenly decide to relegate me to radio Outer Darkness? The answer lies hidden in the oil-and-water incompatibility of these two seemingly disconnected phrases: Criticizing Bush and Clear Channel.
Criticizing Bush? Well then, must I be some sort of rug-chewing liberal? Not even close. As a boy, I stood on the grass in a small Arizona town square when Barry Goldwater officially began his 1964 presidential run. And I was there for the last official event of the Goldwater campaign. My job was to recruit and manage my fellow junior-high and high-school conservatives in a phone bank operation, calling supporters to fill up as many buses as possible to help pack the stadiuma show of strength for the nations television viewers. Of course thats an insignificant role to play in a presidential campaign, but it was pretty heady stuff for a 14-year-old kid from Flagstaff.
I broke with Goldwater in 1976 over his decision to back Gerald Ford instead of Ronald Reagan for the Republican presidential nomination. Ford was a perfectly decent, if ordinary, Republican (who could have taught the big-spending W. Bush a thing or two about the use of the veto!). But I took my conservatism seriously. Reagan was clearly the champion of the conservative cause.
Perhaps Im just anti-military? No. I am proud of my honorable service and of the Army Commendation Medal I was awarded. I also spent a good deal of time in the 1980s as a member of the Speakers Bureau of High Frontier, promoting Reagans Strategic Defense Initiative, a defense policy unlike todays in that it was actually designed to defend the American people.
I have been a Republican precinct committeeman; my county Republican Party elected me its Man of the Year in 1988; I have written speeches for conservative candidates and office holders; and I have been employed by statewide and national political organizations and campaigns, including the National Conservative Political Action Committee. Despite my disappointment in Goldwater for not supporting Reagan, I was there when a small band of the faithfulno more than four or five of usgathered for a potluck dinner to support the creation of a brand-new public-policy think tank named after Mr. Conservative. The enterprise blossomed, and I was honored several months ago to serve as Master of Ceremonies for the Goldwater Institutes 15th Anniversary Gala.
I can assure you then that my criticism of Bush has been on the basis of long-held conservative principles. It begins with respect for the wisdom of the Founders and the Constitutions division of power and delegation of authority, and extends to an adherence to the principles of governmental restraint and fiscal prudence. It proved to be a message that was more than a little inconvenient for my employer.
Clear Channel Communications, the 800-pound gorilla of the radio business, owns an astonishing 1,200 stations in 50 states, including Newstalk 550 KFYI in Phoenix, where I do the afternoon program or did until last summer. The principals of Clear Channel, a Texas-based company, have been substantial contributors to George W. Bushs fortunes since before he became president. In fact, Texas billionaire Tom Hicks can be said to be the man who made Bush a millionaire when he purchased the future presidents baseball team, the Texas Rangers. Tom Hicks is now vice chairman of Clear Channel. Clear Channel stations were unusually visible during the war with what corporate flacks now call pro-troop rallies. In tone and substance, they were virtually indistinguishable from pro-Bush rallies. Im sure the administration, which faced a host of regulatory issues affecting Clear Channel, was not displeased.
Criticism of Bush and his ever-shifting pretext for a first-strike war (what exactly was it we were pre-empting anyway?) has proved so serious a violation of Clear Channels cultural taboo that only a good contract has kept me from being fired outright. Roxanne Cordonier, a radio personality at Clear Channels WMYI 102.5 in Greenville, S.C., didnt have it as good. Cordonier, who worked under the name Roxanne Walker, was the South Carolina Broadcasters Associations 2002 Radio Personality of the Year. That apparently wasnt enough for Clear Channel. Her lawsuit against the company alleges that she was belittled on the air and reprimanded by her station for opposing the invasion of Iraq. Then she was fired.
They couldnt really fire me, at least without paying me a substantial sum of money, but I was certainly belittled on the air for opposing the war. The other KFYI talk-show hostsso bloodthirsty that they made Bush apologists and superhawks Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity sound moderatevilified me almost daily. As a former radio-station owner myself, it was a little hard to believe management would allow one of their key hosts to be trashed day in and day out on their own airwaves. After all, we sell radio time on the basis of its ability to influence peoples behavior. A wiser programming approach would have been to showcase me as an object of curiosity, with a challenge to listeners to see if they could discover where I had gone wrong or how I was missing the imminent threat Iraq posed to the American people. No doubt the constant vilification I received and my heterodoxy on the war cost me audience during the interlude. It was certainly enough to get pictures of me morphing into those of the French president posted on the Free Republic Web site during the freedom fries silliness. A banner there read, Boycott Charles Chirac Goyette at KFYI radio Phoenix, AZ! Protest against the Charles Goyette Show from 4-7pm at KFYI for his leftist subervsive [sic] Bush-bashing rants. Turn off KFYI radio for the Charles Goyette Show! No liberal scum talk shows on KFYI! Radio does provoke people, doesnt it?
One Clear Channel executive had me take an unexpected day off for the sin of reporting the breaking news on March 27, 2003, that neocon hawk Richard Perle, of the Defense Policy Board, had relinquished his chairmanship under scrutiny of his business dealings and for blaspheming that Donald Rumsfeld was the worst Secretary of Defense since Robert McNamara. So great were these transgressions that the radio gods themselves must have been aghast at my impiety. I explained in conference-room confrontations that both positions were completely respectable points of view. The comparison with McNamara had been made repeatedly in subsequent days in the mainstream media. I specifically cited The McLaughlin Group the following Friday and the New York Times the following Monday, and in describing the Perle resignation, I relied upon details from both Seymour Hersh in the New Yorker and from syndicated columnist Arianna Huffington. Well, then, they explained, the problem was the emotionalism of my remarks. Imagine that, emotionalism in talk radio? I reminded them that for years we had run promotions identifying KFYI as the Place with More Passion, where the Charles Goyette Show was positioned as Fearless Talk Radio!
Clear Channel made it clearWith you, I feel like Im managing the Dixie Chicks, said my program directorthat they would have liked to fire me anyway. While a well-drafted contract made that difficult, it did not prevent them from tucking me away outside prime time.
So Im a talk-show war casualty. My contract expires in a few more months andmy iconoclasm being notedit is not likely it will be renewed. Among the survivors at my station: one host who wanted to nuke Afghanistan (he bills himself as your voice of reason and moderation) and another who upon learning that 23-year-old Mideast peace activist Rachel Corrie had been run over by an Israeli bulldozer shouted, Back up and run over her again! As he doesnt quite get some of the important distinctions in these debates, such as that Iranians should not be called Arabs, we would hope that hes not taken too seriously. Likewise my replacements in the afternoon drive slot, brought in for glamorizing the war and billed as The Comedy Channel meets Talk Radio. If you remember the Saturday Night Live skit Superfans with Mike Myers and Chris FarleyWhos stronger, God or da Bulls? Da Bulls!then you get the idea. Only instead of da Bulls, its three hours every afternoon of da Bush! Expect to hear more insightful topics like So Whos Tougher: Michael Jordan or Donald Rumsfeld?
Ive seen how war fever infects a people. And I was in a no-win situation, with an audience pre-screened by virtue of 11 hours a day of screaming war frenzyunlistenable for the uninfectedthat surrounded my time slot. So I knew there would be a personal price for opposing the war, and I was prepared to pay it. But as a lover of the rough and tumble of public debate and the contest of ideas, I am disappointed at what is happening in my industry. At least at Clear Channel, theres only one word for the belief that talk radio is still a fair and fearless search for the truth: Un-Bull-ieveable!
Charles Goyette was named Best Talk Show Host of 2003 by the Phoenix New Times.
My position is that I hope we can take out Iraq and do short term infrastructure building and then leave. We are not doing that now. Iraq I feel will be occupied by America for generations. Sadly, my position (held by many classic conservatives I hope) is complicated and thus no one can articulate it well so Iraq becomes a black and white issue.
PS: I have never heard this radio talk show host before, but I would like to have since his brand of conservativisim (classic) is the kind that attracts me.
Thanks for donating to Free Republic!
Move your locale up the leaderboard!
And, when a liberal newspaper gives you an award for "Best Talk Show Host," you ain't exactly conservative.
You are mistaken. That describes more our ally Suadi Arabia.
By the way-the occupation of Europe and Japan continues. Allowing those nations to divert vast sums to their manufacturing and social sectors.
I recall listening to Goyette while I was there, but I have no recollection of his positions or arguments. Instead, the overriding impression was "overbearing pompous jerk".
Consequently, the station probably had its own reasons for burying him in an overnight slot.
That's funny. Everything I have ever read shows that democracy can not be imposed from outside. In all cases where democracy flourishes a pre-existing condition for its truimph existed. The USA has never been able to impose a democracy on a nation that did not have the foundations for a democracy and the USA has never been able to create anywhere-anytime the foundations that would allow for a democracy to evolve.
Stern? Rush? Bob Grant?
Then they are ignorant of history. If they believe this, then Germany,, Japan, Italy, and South Korea are all subject states of the United States of America. This country has not attempted empire building since the Spanish American War.
These same "anti-war" idiots thought that the Soviet Union's activities vis-a-vis adding "client states" was merely a need for a buffer between them and the war mongering Capitalists.
WABC fires at will!
As does WOR radio.
This guy's so far off the original Goldwater reservation he's somewhere out in the Pacific by now.
...and in describing the Perle resignation, I relied upon details from both Seymour Hersh in the New Yorker and from syndicated columnist Arianna Huffington.
America's Fifth Column ... watch PBS documentary JIHAD! In America
http://12thman.us/media/jihad.rm (Requires RealPlayer)
That doesn't stop us from trying. Over and over.
Of course, one definition of insanity is doing the same thing again and again and expecting a different result.
These anti-war conservatives are not the "same "anti-war" idiots" you describe.
Shame on you for thinking that.
Todd Hartley Prior to creating PHXnews, Todd was at the forefront of radio news in the Valley of the Sun. For example, he hosted a provocative talk show, produced the popular Charles Goyette show, investigated House Speaker Grostcost's role in the alternative fuel scandal, revealed the shady deals and political shenanigans behind the Arizona Cardinals stadium, and covered the Bush/Gore presidential Indecision 2000 from Tallahassee, Florida.
Todd is a graduate of the University of Arizona and a newlywed, recently married to Wendy in September 2002.
I'll be glad to know he's gone. I used to switch my radio off when I had to go shopping or drive anywhere in the evening.
Perhaps if the guy read more he wouldn't find himself unemployed. The fact that he's blaming Clear Channel is your first clue. He just got caught in too many mis-statements IMHO.
Mmmm. Yes. Like Hirohito's Japan? Or Hitler's Germany?
Yes, exactly Like Hirohito's Japan, which before the rule of generals had a liberal (small L) representative modernizing western leaning govt and Hitler's Germany which even before the Weimar Republic had more rights for its citizens under the Kaiser than the British common man enjoyed in the British Empire.
Want to show your ignorance of history again in another example?
I wanna punch your stupid nose down your stupid throat!
Write when you find work, eh?
Now, the Kabbalah Seven -
If that's a crime in the radio world, they'll have to can all the hosts at KFYI. Goyette had points. I was neither for going to war nor completely opposed. I think there were some reasons for going to war but whether they were enough of a reason is really what Goyette was examining. As for Giddy and Shrill, they two who replaced him, I have started listening to FM on the way home...
No thanks, I'm satisfied with the examples I've already given. Prickly one-liners are not the same as meaningful argument.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.