Skip to comments.Bearing Sons 'Can Shorten Mother's Life'
Posted on 11/01/2005 6:14:07 PM PST by blam
Bearing sons 'can shorten mother's life'
By Roger Highfield, Science Editor
Giving birth to and raising several sons could be bad for the long-term health of mothers but good for fathers, according to a study published today.
Scientists suspect that having large families shortens a parent's lifespan, because the effects of reproduction and childcare can take their toll on health. However, in a society without good health care, sons could be especially costly for the mother for several reasons.
They are, on average, born heavier and place more physical stresses on the body. They also raise levels of testosterone in their mothers' bodies, which can age the immune system, making it less able to defend the body.
Sons need more care after birth.
Daughters prolong mothers' lives by helping them in tasks such as obtaining food and rearing their younger siblings, at least in the traditional society studied, so daughters might aid long-term survival.
Today in the Proceedings of the Royal Society: Biological Sciences, Dr Lisa Hurt and Dr Carine Ronsmans of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, working with Dr Maria Quigley of Oxford University, found that this was the case in a poor rural area in Bangladesh.
The study of women in Matlab, where data has been gathered on about 200,000 people, concluded that there are indeed "long term costs of bearing sons".
Mortality increased by 11 per cent with each son born. There was no association between mortality and the number of daughters.
For men there was no clear link between longevity and the numbers of sons born. However, their mortality decreased with each surviving son, while daughters had no effect.
Mom died this year of a brain tumor at the age of 88, she had four boys and two girls.
After raising four sons I guess I'm living on borrowed time.
With two teenage sons, I keep wondering when my aneurysm is going to burst!!!
I'll bet you haven't regretted it at all.
I am so envious of big families. I think they would be such a blessing.
Mom is pushing 80 with no health issues. Of course she drinks and smokes. She had two sons and one daughter. I think my sister has caused my mother more worry than my brother and I.
I raised three and between parachute drops from trees using sheets to Evil Kenevil bike wrecks to the escalated rubberband nail guns and the WMD M80s in the sewers, I'm lucky to still be alive.....
~wouldn't have missed it for the world!
This strikes me as absolute horse manure. The study was probably funded by population controllers and run by abortionists.
Sure, having a baby is no picnic. But we have a ton of kids, and my wife is as healthy as they come.
Other studies have shown that people with stable marriages and children generally are healthy and live longer. So, take your pick.
Not for one minute. We are still a close family.
Roger Highfield wears bloomers.
My mother had 4 boys and one girl. She's still doing well at 85. My father died at 72.
My Grandmother had 10 kids, 6 sons. Lived to be 98. FWIW.
LOL, I bet we could write a book.
My sister also has 4 boys. She's just fine but her husband has been a physical wreck for years.
"My Grandmother had 10 kids, 6 sons. Lived to be 98. FWIW."
Oops, make that 11 kids, 7 sons. Forgot an Uncle. Sheesh.
In "very" traditional times, lack of sons would decrease parents longevity, due to lack of strong arms to defend the homestead
Where the crap did that come from. I've got 2 boys and one girl, had to take care of all of them equally. babies need food, shelter, cleaning and love, regardless of sex. What an idiotic claim.
My son's mother died at 34 of breast cancer. I'm 62 and still kicking. (not real high though)
"The study of women in Matlab, where data has been gathered on about 200,000 people, concluded that there are indeed "long term costs of bearing sons".
LOL, is Matlab a place, or is some math-challenged social science person bragging that they know how to use the Matlab programming language? :)
"...in a poor rural area in Bangladesh."
That is freaking hilarious -- I bet there was a passage in the article stating the analysis was done in Matlab, or some such thing... The reporter, I'm guessing, is the fool.
I have known this for years.
I'll bet having a teenaged daughter is the leading cause of death in males aged 40-60.
the moron who did this "study" no doubt makes a million a year.
Sorry about your Mom...
Speaking as the mom of three sons, they will shorten mine if I don't shorten their lives first LOL!
My great grandmother had 3 sons and 3 daughters who lived to adulthood, and bore two more, one who died in childbirth, and other at age one when one of her children rocked the baby into the fire, and she lived to be 101 (1845-1947).
I hope never that is how my mom died.
Rest her soul
If you listen to my mother it's RAISING them that shortens your life...
Sons are a bigger hassle. Do daughters increase their lifespan however?
My grandparents had 2 daughters and 5 sons. My grandfather died in his early 60s, my grandmother in her mid-80s.
I guess it's not a hard-and-fast rule.
The last time I looked, mortality was very close to 100%, the sole exception being Elijah, who, as I recall, was carried to heaven in a fiery chariot.
I'm sorry for your loss, FRiend!
You said it. I would love to have had more but got started too late in life.
And Enoch who walked with God in Genesis before the Flood. Gen. 5:24
My aunt, who is 96 and still active, will probably outlast me -- and she is the mother of two sons, no daughters, and 3 grandsons, no granddaughters.
Feminists will do anything to get rid of males entirely.
Besides, it's Bush's fault.
Grandma died at 94 after rearing 8 boys and 5 girls. She obviously died before her time.
dang....so am I
My mom, 86 years young, had 6 girls! hmmmmmmm....I suddenly feel very old. 3 sons....26, 24 and 21. I wonder how much longer I have??????
LOL...Bless her Blam, sounds like my Mom.....she's 71 and is tough as nails still.
Stay Safe !
My mother had 4 boys
Lived to 85 and would have lived longer if she hadn't secretly stopped taking her BP medication for a while causing her heart to enlarge
Even if true, having a son is worth every lost minute..
I have 3 sons 22,18,and 17......my advice to young moms of boys is pick your hair color now because gray hair comes early....at least it did for me....still would not trade my boys..... my oldest put me through hell as a youngster but turned out to be a great teen and young man.....love those boys!!!!!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.