Posted on 12/27/2006 7:40:27 AM PST by pabianice
December 27, 2006: Iran continues to predict the imminent destruction of Israel, and promises to do what it can to help make that happen. Israel responds with dark threats of countermeasures that will prevent Iranian plans from working. Most people think that the most likely Israeli response is air strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities. But Israel has another weapon available, but one with serious side effects. Israel has a satellite launch capability that could put a nuclear weapon in low orbit (about 200 kilometers up). Once over Iran, the nuclear bomb could be detonated, and create an EMP (Electromagnetic Pulse), which would destroy most of the military and civilian electronics in Iran. That would be a major setback to the Iranian nuclear weapons program, and the Iranian economy. There would be ugly side effects. The nuclear blast would also create a temporary belt of intense radiation, which would destroy or damage many of the low earth orbit satellites up there. There would be $100 billion, or more, in damage to these satellites, and several years of disrupted communications, GPS and weather prediction service until all the damaged satellites could be replaced. It's this collateral damage, more than anything else, that protects Iran from this kind of attack.
Then again, what's to prevent Iran or North Korea from setting off a nuke in low orbit, just to mess up everyone's satellites? Sounds like a great extortion opportunity. This is one reason more and more satellites are being hardened to resist the kind of radiation surge high altitude EMP would produce. But most of the stuff in low orbit is not hardened, and even the birds that are so protected, are not invulnerable to EMP, just less vulnerable.
--b--
Interesting. Thanks for posting.
Get 'er done!
> This is just one of the dangers in dropping all other nav aids in favor of GPS, a system than can be shut-down by an enemy, leaving the U.S. with little upon which to fall back. <
Does anybody in our Navy or Air Force remember how to do celestial navigation? If not, we're probably doomed as a military power.
There are also non nuclear means of generating EMP, though the effects are not as wide spread as with a sub orbital nuke.
Bump!
GPS isn't in low earth orbit, they are 12,000 miles up. There are 24 of them so it would be hard to knock out more than one or two at a time, and since they only last 10 years there are almost always 3 or 4 ready to be launched each year, so replacing one or two that get taken out by an enemy could happen in a matter of weeks.
My former Congressman, Curt Weldon, has been warning about the threat of EMP for many years. It's a #$%@ shame that he will not be in COngress next term to keep up the fight. To my fellow Pennsylvanians who were stupid enough to vote the Dem ticket, good effing luck getting the same support from a Clinton/Berger tool like Sestak.
small neutron burns over the parliament while in session and their military bases would be better......along with a few bunker-busters for the underground stuff, of course
Does anyone know how, in basic terms, one would "harden" a satellite in orbit against an EMP? I suppose there's no place up there to ground it.
Actually, yes. Several ships I was on (former USN) the navigator always had a sextant handy in case the on-board navigation equipment failed. During daylight hours, shooting a "sun line" gave a pretty good indication of where we were - and at night there are several stars to pick for the same purpose. Always have a backup!
Grounding of a satellite is rather simple. You attach the grounding strap to the sky hook (thingy that keeps the satellite from falling). Don't hesitate to ask more questions.
Both Navy and Air Force navigators are trained in celestial navigation. There is a section of the pentagon that is charged with devising methods to complete missions when everything goes wrong.
Our military has never ever put all its eggs in one basket. It is nearly always several steps ahead of its worst critics.
LOL!
Most people can't even find the north star these days. If you ask most kids these days they immediately point the the brightest thing in the sky at the moment.
"Grounding of a satellite is rather simple."
I grounded mine last night... "No TV for a week!"
What navigational aids would function in the event of a nuclear exchange sufficient to knock out big chunks of the GPS constellation? The only other one I know is Loran, and I'm pretty sure that would get fried, too.
Betcha 10 to one somebody has bent back the grounding prong on the cord to make it fit...
It's worse than you think: back in the 1980s, the purely opto-mechanical averagers on airborne sextants were replaced with electronic averagers. Yes, it was faster. . .but fry the chips, and you're SOL. And the mechanical averagers didn't need aircraft power either...
"Both Navy and Air Force navigators are trained in celestial navigation. There is a section of the pentagon that is charged with devising methods to complete missions when everything goes wrong."
Glad to hear it. That's why I enjoy this site so much.
Not to mention all fuel injected auto's would be rendered useless. Makes one want to keep a cheapo carbureted dirt bike around...
Womder if the field artillery still learns manual fire direction? Went to Ft. Stewart for an FDC course back in the 80s that was built around the then fairly new BUCS. We still had to learn to use charge sticks and firing tables and do manual met reports along with plotting everything on the chart tables, index lines, firing points, and safety T's. I always figured we's be SOL if the batteries died.
I'm with you. Let's do it to them before they do it to us.
How about they have to get it there first? And that will be a very long time.
Correct. There's the quick and dirty method and then there's the surgical strike method.
Last time I went up I used IFR---I follow roads.
Works for me. I do wonder if LORAN could be brought back...
"Faraday cages can be built to totally enclose sensitive equipment not in use. This subject is covered in more detail at this link for Faraday cages. In general, the equipment is placed in a metal or foil covered box, insulated on the inside, and preferably grounded. Exposed radios and similar equipment are extremely difficult to protect, particularly if they are plugged into a 110 volt household electric circuit. In that case, spare equipment stored in Faraday cages would be most advantageous. If the Faraday cages are sitting on a conductive surface, they should be grounded. Grounding is safer in any case, though. The second problem, long line accumulation of an EMP surge, requires isolation of equipment and proper grounding, so the EMP pulse has an easier path to earth than through the equipment. Ground rods should be driven down to wet earth, if at all possible, to provide a sufficient ground. That may mean an 8 foot ground rod, or even longer, depending upon your location."
Credit to End Times Report.
Most Iowans know how to find North by using a standard(non-digital, non-electric watch. I do not fear EMP beyond the initial change. Oh, and the fact I won't be able to play my PS3.
Trivial... as compared to what it would do here or in any western nation.
They're a lot closer to the Stone Age already. Not as far for them to fall.
That won't protect the ICs. The chips will be damaged internally, chassis grounded or not.
Yes, we can orbit a few replacements (probably on much shorter notice than advertised if we militarily really need to). But there will be a period of time (pessimistically a few weeks, optimistically a few hours) where GPS is degraded significantly. And now everybody (from car drivers to airplanes and ships) use GPS
I think that two weeks of "shock and awe" on their governmental, military, and infrastructure would do the trick.
The people of Iran do not want their leaders, nor the religious nuts that run the country. They would do the rest.
We should move to a strategy of using air power and leaving the cleanup to the people.
Doesn't Iran have all their sensitive military HQ underground, where it would be safe ? I think I remember reading that.
I want the handheld version of this device so I can fry the electronics in the car of all those a**holes who drive slow in the passing lane on the freeway...
True, but the Starfish test occured in a more robust electronic environment, as opposed to the ultra miniturized current state of technology.
Of course, 20 jihadis with dynamite taking down spreadout transmission towers during peak deman time would probably be about as effective to shutting down the grid.
The military has been aware of this potential problem for decades and took steps decades ago to remedy it. I know because in the early 80's I was a computer repairman in the Air Force and ten year old equipment had EMP proof circuitry in them.
Back in the 80s, the DIA spent a lot of money with GE and Harris to develop rad-hardened, EMP resistant RAM, processors and gate arrays using exotic materials. For the most part they were successful.
A hardened satellite would use those materials as well as conventional shielding.
A scientist on the project once told me that most unexplained computer crashes were caused by a hot particle passing through your RAM and flipping its state.
"Then again, what's to prevent Iran or North Korea from setting off a nuke in low orbit, just to mess up everyone's satellites?"
For one thing, the advanced nations can tune their bombs to give off more or less emp. They may even be able to make shaped emp blasts for all I know.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Very good! (How could that be compressed into a tagline...?)
"That won't protect the ICs."
My 67 Camaro doesn't have no stinkin ICs.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.