Skip to comments.How Dogs Became Man's Best Friend Video
Posted on 01/26/2007 2:44:05 PM PST by afraidfortherepublic
click here to read article
I have a two Moluccans. One is a self mutilator,and I put that in the lap of her breeder/owners. She never was taught how to be a bird. My other 'too is her name, Diva. Not only does she think she's a bird, but a bird WAY prettier the rest of us.
My cats are independent and comforting in thet fact that aren't needy. My dog? He's my Buddy.
I am a little puzzled about this article. Is the 5-minute video "it"? Or is there a scheduled expanded version scheduled to be aired sometime on PBS stations as one of the "Wild Chronicles" - National Geographic hour programs?
My local PBS station in Sacramento, California does not seem to have a record of it.
Love the video about Kenzie & Barney. That is an excellent first post! I'll have to get to work and my high speed line to watch te rest of the videos. Thanks for posting.
That's a WONDERFUL video. I've seen that pair on TV before. I'm sure they were contestants on Pet Star a couple of years ago. THanks for posting.
I don't know any more about it. I just picked up the video from the Web.
I'm jealous. We can't get it at my house yet, but my "neighbor" has it 1 1/2 miles away. The best I can get is Road Runner, but it is twice as expensive, and I don't trust having all of my utilities in the same hands (RR -- Time Warner Cable -- wants to take over the phone service too.)
Don't know whether you went to the National Geo video but your video points out exactly the researcher's conclusion.
Dogs sense,pick up cues from humans that wolves, even chimps don't.
I've seen the video before, amazing.
What's your point?
Those who have successful skilled working dogs are not the people who seek out the help of Cesar Milan. The people with spoiled pets are. And on those, he pretty much tells people to stop spoiling them and to treat them like dogs. So what's the problem?
I agree with Hairofthedog. Cesar has no reason to help people with dogs like that because they are already training them and seem to have just the skills needed to do so. Most of the dogs Cesar deals with DON'T have jobs, and that is part of the problem. They're coddled, they run the house, and most of them aren't even given proper exercise. No wonder they're a handful!
You and ~I~ don't live in different worlds, I also grew up around animals. His clients are largely untrained people who did not have the benefit of learning from you in 4H class. You're just being an arrogant curmudgeon because something about his fame and fortune has gotten under your skin.
If it wasn't for people like him showing the rest of the non-working dog training world, little ankle biters and big dogs with big problems would never change, or their owners wouldn't, I should say. Of course, in an area where animals are used for work and show instead of lawn ornaments, you would need someone more adept at handling those kinds of animals. But his show is about regular "city" people and their inability to simply be the boss.
Cesar makes it very clear on his show that he does NOT train the dogs. He trains the owners on how to handle them. He came from Mexico as an illegal alien, admits he hasn't been certified and learned his techniques while working as a groomer or kennel person, and seems pretty modest about what he does. His whole show is about clueless owners and I think even though some of the cases I have seen will probably never change, overall his work has had positive results.
If the "city" people's dogs had real jobs, they wouldn't need him in the first place. Most of what he seems to tell these owners is that they don't do well with no work, no exercise, mixed signals, and inconsistency. People with working dogs don't have to experience this because their dogs are trained and kept busy.
|GGG managers are SunkenCiv, StayAt HomeMother & Ernest_at_the_Beach|
Note: this topic is dated 1/26/2007.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.