Nurses in Katrina Euthanasia Case Offered Immunity for Grand Jury Testimony

LifeSiteNews ^ | 6/21/07 | Hilary White

[P-40]

Isn’t the answer obvious?

[Grizzled Bear]

I know that you have never been faced with a set of choices where all of the available outcomes are bad, really bad...but you still have to choose.

---

You are amazing! Please give me next weeks Lotto numbers, Thanx!

[BykrBayb]

That all depends. Do you have air conditioning,food in the refrigerator, clean water from the faucets, and emergency services a phone call away? If you do, then you don’t understand that they should have been killed. If you don’t, then you understand that they should have been killed. /s

[PFC]

I will not second guess what those people did under those circumstances. If I was dying and in horrible pain living in those hellish conditions, I would hope someone would have the compassion to shoot me up with something.

But -- there is not even a whole lot of evidence that is what happenned. The main "witness" is a publicity hound with a track record of being tossed out of hospitals. Foti, the state D.A., filed the charges as a payback to trial lawyres for funding his campaign.

[P-40]

Some people just never make that connection to the rest of humanity.

Some people can have a connection to humanity and to reality at the same time. Some people just curl up in a ball and avoid reality when it comes knocking.

And the shooting down of the aircraft example is from a drill mentioned in the 9/11 Commission Report on what to do if a plane was hijacked and the hijackers were threatening to fly it into a building. The question was left unresolved.

[BykrBayb]

Save your dollar. It was a really bad guess.

[Grizzled Bear]

Ah, so if the United States still maintained the alert sites it once did, so that armed aircraft could be launched instantly, and a pilot would have been available to shoot down the second aircraft before it could have crashed into the WTC, he would be a murderer?

---

If a terminally ill patient was flying low at a high velocity on an intended collision course with a building I guess the right thing to do would be to shoot them down.

I just hope their hospital gown is closed at the back. It would be very undignified to be shot out of the sky while mooning the general population.

[BykrBayb]

There is no conflict between humanity and reality. You cannot have one without the other.

[Grizzled Bear]

I wish I could live in such a black and white world. Unfortunately, reality in this one is not so kind.

---

I’m glad I don’t see murderous terrorists as having moral equivalence with nursing home patients.

[Grizzled Bear]

It still never ceases to amaze me that there are people running around on the loose who openly advocate murder. I keep waiting for the catch, or the punch line.

---

It’s usually something like “Zieg Heil!”

[BykrBayb]

J

[P-40]

Murder is wrong. Try to stay on topic.

What you call murder is not always wrong, in the pure sense. That is the topic, is it not? I find it amusing you avoid discussing anything that doesn't fit your pure moral model. Incidentally, this sort of scenario was what I submitted for one of the questions of the potential presidential candidates. It was rejected....but there was something about underwear once.

[BykrBayb]

“Zieg Heil!”

"This person suffering from hereditary
defects costs the people 60,000
Reichmarks during his lifetime. People,
that is your money. Read 'New People'."

[nicmarlo]

Later, two doctors admitted that patients were euthanized, one doctor saying that he had fled the hospital rather than directly participate in killing patients.

Good doc! BQ, remember all this insanity down there?

[P-40]

If a terminally ill patient was flying low at a high velocity on an intended collision course with a building I guess the right thing to do would be to shoot them down.

So you would murder them?

[BykrBayb]

This thread is not about the campaign, 9/11 or underwear.

[darkangel82]

So what’s it like to have no conscience?

[P-40]

There is no conflict between humanity and reality. You cannot have one without the other.

If you understood that then you would know that sometimes humanity requires some absolutely brutal choices. That is reality.

[Grizzled Bear]

Isn’t the answer obvious?

---

In your post #36 to BykrBayb made an accusation of them avoiding the question.

Are you saying that the patients were better off murdered rather than evacuated.

Is Brazil nice this time of year, Dr Mengele?

[Grizzled Bear]

That all depends. Do you have air conditioning,food in the refrigerator, clean water from the faucets, and emergency services a phone call away? If you do, then you don’t understand that they should have been killed. If you don’t, then you understand that they should have been killed. /s

---

I have a big screen TV but it’s an old Hitachi. I don’t have a Plasma Screen.

Do I get to decide who lives or dies? /SARC