Skip to comments.Hsu Seeks to Have California Case Dropped
Posted on 10/25/2007 4:03:56 PM PDT by Libloather
Hsu Seeks to Have Calif. Case Dropped
By PAUL ELIAS, Associated Press Writer
AP - Friday, October 26
SAN FRANCISCO - Disgraced political donor Norman Hsu wasn't hiding from anyone over the past few years, his lawyers say. If California authorities really wanted to find him, they could have asked Hillary Rodham Clinton or one of the other prominent Democrats he showered with cash donations.
Hsu is asking a judge to toss his 15-year-old felony fraud conviction, arguing that his right to a speedy trial was violated because authorities weren't actively pursuing him. They could easily have arrested Hsu, his lawyers argue, at one of the swank fundraisers he hosted in California for prominent local politicians including Rep. Doris Matsui, D-Sacramento.
"Mr. Hsu lived an open and public life and the government made no apparent efforts to arrest him," attorney James Brosnahan wrote in court papers filed last week. "He did not act like a fugitive. He did not evade the authorities, but rather openly associated with highly public officials."
State prosecutors filed their own documents Tuesday arguing that Hsu shouldn't benefit from his flight from justice, even if he was hiding in plain sight. That would "stand the criminal justice system on its head," deputy attorney general Ronald Smetana wrote.
Hsu's troubles began dogging Clinton and other big-name Democrats this summer when news reports revealed he was a fugitive who fled the state before he was sentenced for a 1992 fraud conviction. He turned himself in on Aug. 31 _ then fled again.
He was recaptured last month after he tried to kill himself by overdosing on drugs aboard an eastbound Amtrak train in Colorado. Hsu is being held without bail in a Redwood City jail.
In recent years, Hsu became a top political fundraiser, donating generously to Democratic candidates and causes and raising much more from other contributors. Since his fall from grace, many of those donations were given to charity or returned. The Clinton campaign pledged to divest $850,000 raised by Hsu.
On Nov. 2, Hsu's attorneys will ask a San Mateo County Superior Court judge to dismiss the fraud case, in which Hsu pleaded no contest to charges he bilked investors out of $1 million. He faces up to three years in prison.
If Brosnahan fails get the case dismissed outright, he says he will then ask that Hsu be allowed to withdraw his 1992 plea because the judge who accepted it and was scheduled to sentence Hsu before he fled has since retired. If Hsu succeeds in taking back his plea, his case goes back to square one and could then go to trial.
"Mr. Hsu has the right to have the same judge who accepted his plea impose sentence," Brosnahan wrote in court papers.
Smetana says investigators periodically checked Hsu's former apartment, his wife's home and his son's school in the years following his disappearance. But he concedes investigators stopped looking for him after they became convinced he had left the country for Asia.
Still, the arrest warrant remained active, Smetana argues, and he refused a court clerk's 1998 request to take it off the books.
Smetana also said previous California cases have allowed another judge to sentence criminals after the retirement of the judge who originally handled the case.
Even if Hsu manages to succeed in getting out from under the California charges, he still faces fresh federal felony charges in New York. He's charged there with operating two Ponzi schemes, in California and New York, that defrauded investors of a combined $60 million. He's also accused of pressuring investors to make campaign contributions, and giving others money to make donations.
He also faces two competing lawsuits filed by aggrieved investors who said Hsu duped them out of the $60 million federal officials accuse him of stealing. Federal investigators found little trace of that money when they seized Hsu's bank accounts and other assets last month.
The new set of allegedly jilted investors will also have a hard time getting any of the $2 million cash bail Hsu forfeited when he skipped a Sept. 5 court date in Redwood City. Hsu wants the money back, but prosecutors will ask the judge next week to put $2 million into a special account to reimburse victims of Hsu's 1990s scam.
Ronald Minkoff, a lawyer for a New York investment group suing Hsu for $40 million, said he's disappointed the campaigns didn't heed his call to place the tainted funds into a special account until an equitable distribution system could be set up.
"Federal regulations don't give the candidates a lot of options," said Minkoff, conceding that the candidates would have to get "creative" to get around election finance laws to set up the accounts he contemplated.
"There's nothing in the federal regulations that deals with the notion that someone would steal money and then give it to a political campaign," Minkoff said.
"I'm deeply saddened..."
Ah, so !
If the Hsu don’t fit, you must acquit !!
I think we are about to find out how broken our system is.
Utter Rubbish, He had his trial and was CONVICTED AND SENTENCED
TOTALLY BROKEN except for DEMOCRATS.
Don’t be surprised if the Clinton Machine gets him off.
That’s okay with hillary. She now has all the dishwashers in new yawk donating a thousand to 12 hundred for her campaign. Apparently they are immigrants. Go figure.
Now that's real Hsuchutzpah.
Thanks Calpernia. Pinging everyone; look at the picture at # 8.
Hsu is asking a judge to toss his 15-year-old felony fraud conviction
A Clinton friendly judge, no doubt.
Good luck making that argument Mr. Hsu. Probably get a good belly-laugh from the judge before he smacks your attorney down.
Malaysia News on Yahoo?
They buried this one mighty deep..
Thought it was a crAPpleface piece at first
Her eyes really look bipolar.
âRonald Minkoff, a lawyer for a New York investment group suing Hsu for $40 million, said heâs disappointed the campaigns (H Clintonâs) didnât heed his call to place the tainted funds into a special account until an equitable distribution system (More Chinese Cooks and Dishwashers) could be set up.â
Yes, but only in regards to the democrats:
"...asked Hillary Rodham Clinton or one of the other prominent Democrats he showered with cash donations."
"...dogging Clinton and other big-name Democrats"
"...fundraisers he hosted in California for prominent local politicians including Rep. Doris Matsui, D-Sacramento."
"In recent years, Hsu became a top political fundraiser, donating generously to Democratic candidates..."
If we here at fr concentrate more on telling folks to google "Clinton National Security Scandal and Coverup" - then perhaps/hopefully "the questions" will be answered.
Your link/ good find.
Welcome to Thugsville, open your pocketbooks!
Thugsville is a lot cleaner then the terms that came to my mind ^-^
Hey, it’s Friday. Getting a late start...
That seems to be a totally inane argument on the part of Hsu and his lawyer. As I understand it, he had already had a trial and became a fugitive after his conviction. So what is the relevance of the state government's apparent lack of interest in him during the fugitive period, to a lack of speed in getting him to trial? None, zilch, nada, if those are indeed the facts.
Thanks for the ping!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.