Posted on 05/10/2008 12:07:06 AM PDT by Ethan Clive Osgoode
Priya Venkatesan ‘90, a former Writing 5 lecturer and research associate at Dartmouth Medical School, is threatening to name seven of her former students in a potential civil rights lawsuit against the College, DMS and Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, Venkatesan announced Friday. Venkatesan also plans to write an autobiographical book that will include details of her experience at Dartmouth and name the seven students in question, all of whom were members of her Winter term Writing 5 class in 2008, she said.
Venkatesan is considering suing the College for harassment and discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, which protects against employment discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex and national origin.
The suit would likely name faculty members as well, including Tom Cormen, chair of the writing program at the College, and DMS professor Christopher Lowrey. Cormen declined to comment, and Lowrey did not return requests for comment by press time.
Venkatesan, who said she left Dartmouth voluntarily on March 17, contends that she was subjected to “inappropriate and unprofessional” behavior while at the College. Venkatesan contacted a New Hampshire lawyer on Friday to determine whether she had grounds for a potential lawsuit. She will speak with the lawyer again on Monday, she said. Venkatesan refused to disclose the name of the attorney.
“I think that I have a good case because there were just so many instances – it was almost an incessant barrage – of hostility, nastiness and anti-intellectualism that I may just in fact have a case, but I’m not a lawyer,” Venkatesan said in an interview with The Dartmouth.
Venkatesan got in touch with a literary agent a few days ago, she said. She said the book and the lawsuit are separate issues.
“Even if I do not have any recourse to the law, I still feel like my story should get out there, and I should try to pursue publication,” Venkatesan said, adding that she is pursuing a lawsuit because she believes her civil rights may have been violated, not in order to promote her book.
Students were first informed of a possible lawsuit in an e-mail from Venkatesan sent on April 25, according to one student from Venkatesan’s class. The student is not one of those Venkatesan named as a potential defendant in the suit.
Behavior in the class did not rise to the level of harassment or discrimination, the student said, although many students stopped paying attention in class and complained about Venkatesan to Cormen. Students believed that Venkatesan did not accept opinions contrary to her own and would lower the grades of students who disagreed with her, the student said. The median grade in the class was a B, according to the Registrar’s website. All other sections of Writing 5 had a median grade of B+ or higher that term.
“We didn’t like her because she was not a good teacher, and she wasn’t very open to others’ ideas,” the student said. “It had nothing to do with her race or anything like that.”
As an example of Venkatesan’s rejection of views different from her own, the student highlighted Venkatesan’s cancelation of class for a week after the class applauded a student who contradicted Venkatesan’s opinions about post-modernism.
Venkatesan said the incident occurred when she was lecturing about “The Death of Nature,” a book by Carolyne Merchant, and the witch trials of the Renaissance. The student went on a “diatribe” about the inappropriate nature of challenging patriarchal authority, Venkatesan said. Vakatesan respected the student’s right to express this opinion, she said, but the manner in which he vocalized his views and the applause afterward were disrespectful and offensive.
“I was horrified,” Venkatesan said. “My responsibility is not to stifle them, but when they clapped at his comment, I thought that crossed the line … I was facing intolerance of ideas and intolerance of freedom of expression.”
Venkatesan contacted Cormen about the event, she said, but claims she received no support from him. She canceled class because the incident caused her “intellectual and emotional distress,” she said. This event, which occurred on Feb. 1, would likely be included in a list of grievances relating to a potential lawsuit, she said.
Following the incident, Venkatesan expressed her dissatisfaction with the class, and the student expected Venkatesan to respond to the situation, likely with an angry e-mail, but had not expected anything on the level of a potential lawsuit, the student said.
“I was just stunned,” the student said. “I didn’t know what to do. I just thought it was really ridiculous…It’s not really a great situation for her, but I feel like this is mostly because she’s upset about something.”
Venkatesan also said she was exposed to a “barrage of offensive behavior” while working as a researcher in the medical school. Venkatesan, whose specialty is the intersection of science and literature, said many of her academic interpretations of science in the context of literary theory during laboratory meetings were received in a “hostile,” “demeaning” and “anti-intellectual” manner by her colleagues.
“I understand that there are such things as bad working environments — a shithole is just a shithole, and that’s not illegal, and I know that,” she said. “But sometimes you have to take time out and address the issue of justice in society and to really implement the values that are so lacking at Dartmouth.”
The lawyer Venkatesan contacted advised her to create a chronology of events, including dates and names of individuals involved, that she felt constituted harassment or discrimination. Venkatesan has sent this partially-completed chronology of approximately 15 events to Ethan Dmitrovsky, chair of the pharmacology and toxicology department at DMS, and Charles Mannix, chief operating officer of DMS, she said. She should complete the chronology by Monday, she said, and will wait for a response from the two men before deciding whether to continue with any legal action.
Students in Venkatesan’s class were invited to a meeting at Parkhurst Administration Building with Dean of First Year Students Gail Zimmerman, a legal counsel and others, the student in the class said, although the student did not attend the meeting.
Dartmouth General Counsel Bob Donin does not believe Venkatesan’s lawsuit has legal merit, he said in a statement e-mailed to The Dartmouth.
“It has come to our attention that a former faculty member has e-mailed some undergraduates and faculty members mentioning the possibility of legal action,” Donin said in the statement. “We have determined that there is no basis for such action, and we have advised the students and faculty members of this.”
Venkatesan took a position at a large research university on April 14. She said she was uncomfortable naming the institution.
Dmitrovsky, Mannix and Zimmerman did not return requests for comment by press time.
From her bio...
After obtaining a BA from Dartmouth College, I have an MS in Genetics from UC Davis and a PhD in Literature from UC San Diego. My first book, Molecular Biology in Narrative Form, was just released. My current position is as Postdoctoral Fellow in the Department of Medicine at Dartmouth Medical School, which will form the basis of my latest manuscript, A Postmodernist in the Laboratory.Mendacious modern academics.
Has she gotten an estimate of how much it will cost to remove the corn cob from her butt?
Nice to see despite decades of PC indoctrination med students are still not willing to swallow the BS.
“Intersection of science and literature” my a##....
While with the military for so many years...I took a fair amount of classes which the Air Force paid for. Going from base to base...I probably had fifty different instructors throughout my class career. At least ten of them were individuals who knew nothing about the subject. Two guys barely spoke English. One was a homeless out-of-work Geology professor who was sleeping in her Volkswagen van behind her sister’s house in Tacoma. I had one professor who was on some kind of pain medication and slurred every third word for the entire semester.
I would agree that there are some great professors out there....but for each ten of these guys....there are at least three professors who should not be teaching and would be better managers of some Baskin Robbins.
I don't know, she can use the proceeds of the lawsuit cover that. Her book is up on Amazon and judging by the 1 customer review it is clear why her students rebelled. Here's a synopsis from elsewhere:
Priya Venkatesan Hays takes an interdisciplinary approach to achieve a secure and functional connection between molecular biology and French narrative theory. Using the notion that science, specifically DNA is a set of codes and literature is in the form of another set of codes, she explores the semiotic possibilities of interaction. Given this bridge, the projects and agendas of scientists and narratologists become closer than previously imagined. Although she will obviously appeal to those interested in epistemology per se, Hays also has created a model for those seeking linkages between other fields that appear to be mutually exclusive. For the literary-minded she explains the processes of molecular biology she uses; for others she also explains the equivalent narrative theory. For both, she builds toward a reassessment of molecular biology in the context of advancing a narrative analysis, works on a semiotics of scientific discovery, and provides historical and sociological frameworks from narrative and semiotic perspectives.
I know this all too well. On the flip side there are some professor who are absolutley brilliant and know the subject inside and out, but have no speaking or teaching skills at all. Also I am a student of geology, don’t assume we are all hippies who drive a VW bus.
A Postmodernist in the Laboratory - this is her book?
I don’t expect to see it anytime soon on the best seller list!
Yep, definitely a cure for insomnia.
Don't know how much it would cost, but they would either have to blast or get a D-8 Caterpillar with some heavy anchor chain to pull it out.
The Law stoops not to trifles.
Ms. Venkatesan's scholarly specialty is "science studies," which, as she wrote in a journal article last year, "teaches that scientific knowledge has suspect access to truth." She continues: "Scientific facts do not correspond to a natural reality but conform to a social construct."After a winter of discontent, the snapping point came while Ms. Venkatesan was lecturing on "ecofeminism," which holds, in part, that scientific advancements benefit the patriarchy but leave women out. One student took issue, and reasonably so – actually, empirically so.
Ms. Venkatesan informed her pupils that their behavior was "fascist demagoguery." Then, after consulting a physician about "intellectual distress," she cancelled classes for a week. Thus the pending litigation.
ping
LOL! The Brave New World where everyone has the right to a 4.0 GPA.
http://freedomeden.blogspot.com/2008/04/priya-venkatesan.html
From a cursory perusal, I feel confident in saying that she is definitely guilty of something.
Thanks!
(I wrote “adept” when I meant “inept.”
But that’s the “guilty” picture, alright!!!
“lecturer”
“My responsibility is not to stifle them, but when they clapped at his comment, I thought that crossed the line … I was facing intolerance of ideas and intolerance of freedom of expression.”
Lulz. Find video of people clapping for her at her lectures.
Close down immigration until we can assimilate these pigs with traditional American values.
Suing your way to fame and fortune is not the American way.
Like, wow, there was like, OMG, just SOooo many, you know, instances.
What has happened to our education system?
Allan Bloom has the answer.
Have you ever been to the Post Modern generator?
It is hilarious:
http://www.elsewhere.org/pomo/
These ‘academicians’ have one goal in mind: fame and fortune. In this regard, they represent the worst of the Capitalists they condemn.
What the heck is “intellectual distress?” Woman, if your ideas can’t hack it in the world and aren’t accepted and you can’t deal with that, I must ask what you’re doing in academia. Your sole aim in all of this is to teach and practice the defense of ideas. If the weight of a counter-argument sends you sprawling in all directions, it’s time you set off to lighter burdens in a job where the central nature of your job isn’t open for public debate.
I hope this lawsuit gets the proper 10 secons of consideration it deserves before being discarded as the waste of paper that it is.
Curiously it seems self-evident folks like this _really_ don’t like their picture taken. Or more likely, published I see this a lot with goofball academes, obscure bureaucrat/politicians/social policy wonks. Better to remain under the radar is the name of the game. A lawsuit precludes this, though.
I’m certain this is satire or, an example as to what passes for humor in elite circles.
Guilty!
Reminds me of the closing summary of a lawyer in a car crash case, quoted in Physics Today:
"The laws of physics are obeyed in the laboratory but not in rural New Jersey."
Fire her sorry ass and strip her of her degree. She has no business anywhere *near* science OR a classroom.
Cheers!
Talk about a wild-eyed stare!
Those aren’t eyes, they’re headlights!
;^)
Students told me that most of the "problems" owed to her impenetrable lectures and various eruptions when students indicated skepticism of literary theory. She counters that such skepticism was "intolerant of ideas" and "questioned my knowledge in very inappropriate ways." Ms. Venkatesan, who is of South Asian descent, also alleges that critics were motivated by racism, though it is unclear why."
... um because it was the handiest thing she could use in court and in order to promote her upcoming book?
She'd fit right in, in fact, get lost in the shuffle at Portland U.
If this twit had been smart enough she'd have gone into the"global warming" and "climate change" field of "science", where "social constructs" really do trump scientific facts and natural reality... she'd have fit right in there, and been hailed as a "visionary"... /grin
“Her book is up on Amazon and judging by the 1 customer review it is clear why her students rebelled. Here’s a synopsis from elsewhere:”
Is that a joke or serious? Semiotics and DNA?
The average grade in these classes was a B+ or better? So much for higher learning.
Pay your tuition and graduate, attendance and study are optional.
If given the chance, the postmodernists will do for science what they did for literature and art. The eco-fanatics are already deconstructing science in the name of the global warming religion. This is getting dangerous when people believe that there is no reality - that everything is a social construct and a figment of the imagination. If an airplane lands safely or if its wings fall off, is it just a meaningless "construct" of the observer? If a drug cures an illness or poisons someone to death, is it just a random matter of someone's perspective? Do you want to be operated on by a "surgeon" who thinks that there is objectively no difference between removing your appendix and cutting off your head -- it's all an illusion anyway? I can just imagine a postmodernist professor of agriculture "teaching" that plants do not exist and one cannot make them grow and that people starving to death is a great type of "performance art." Where would it end? If the pre-modern Islamists don't kill us, the postmodernists will.
What a joke. SHe needs some cheeeze with that whine.
WOW!
I know what that is, and you rarely see a quote like that!
Wow again!
Basically, she’s just PO’d because they gave her an F.
Tough noogies, prof.
Google-Priya Venkatesan
In case you hadn’t heard, Dartmouth lecturer Priya Venkatesan has dropped the discrimination lawsuit she inexplicably filed against her former students. Hopefully it’ll still all end up in the book! Venkatesan is now a research assistant at Northwestern .
You are exactly right.
“I understand that there are such things as bad working environments — a shithole is just a shithole, and that’s not illegal, and I know that,” she said.”
And sometimes a whiny bitch is just a whiny bitch.... good grief...
Good grief. The real crime here is paying money to be taught this nonsense.
Pretentious goobly gook.
“incessant barrage – of hostility, nastiness and anti-intellectualism”
Oh, yeah... That seems like a good lawsuit.
This is what happens when trailor trash gets a Ph.D.
I've wanted to sue their parents for coddling them, or their high schools for stuffing their heads full of trash -- or for letting them graduate at all, though.
This woman is a LOSER! She graduated in 1990 (with a bachelor’s I suppose) and got her PhD (when?) and still a research associate (apparently at Northwestern). If she’s really smart, she’d been a real prof by now. No wonder her students ridicule her (if true)!
A key tenet of Postintellectual Modernism.
LOL - I read your sentence three times trying to figure out how to connect "adept" with "declined". :)
A testament to my adeptitude with the English language.
Whatever. How long did it take you to get your PhD?
4 years.
Did you sneak up on her when you took that picture?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.