| View this table: [in a new window]  |
Data on Suicides in States with the Highest and Lowest Rates of Gun Ownership, 2001–2005.
|
Posted on 09/03/2008 6:58:42 PM PDT by neverdem
This past June, in a 5-to-4 decision in District of Columbia v. Heller, the Supreme Court struck down a ban on handgun ownership in the nation's capital and ruled that the District's law requiring all firearms in the home to be locked violated the Second Amendment. But the Supreme Court's finding of a Second Amendment right to have a handgun in the home does not mean that it is a wise decision to own a gun or to keep it easily accessible. Deciding whether to own a gun entails balancing potential benefits and risks. One of the risks for which the empirical evidence is strongest,1 and the risk whose death toll is greatest, is that of completed suicide.
In 2005, the most recent year for which mortality data are available, suicide was the second-leading cause of death among Americans 40 years of age or younger. Among Americans of all ages, more than half of all suicides are gun suicides. In 2005, an average of 46 Americans per day committed suicide with a firearm, accounting for 53% of all completed suicides. Gun suicide during this period accounted for 40% more deaths than gun homicide.
Why might the availability of firearms increase the risk of suicide in the United States? First, many suicidal acts — one third to four fifths of all suicide attempts, according to studies — are impulsive. Among people who made near-lethal suicide attempts, for example, 24% took less than 5 minutes between the decision to kill themselves and the actual attempt, and 70% took less than 1 hour.2
Second, many suicidal crises are self-limiting. Such crises are often caused by an immediate stressor, such as the breakup of a romantic relationship, the loss of a job, or a run-in with police. As the acute phase of the crisis passes, so does the urge to attempt suicide. The temporary nature and fleeting sway of many suicidal crises is evident in the fact that more than 90% of people who survive a suicide attempt, including attempts that were expected to be lethal (such as shooting oneself in the head or jumping in front of a train), do not go on to die by suicide. Indeed, recognizing the self-limiting nature of suicidal crises, penal and psychiatric institutions restrict access to lethal means for persons identified as potentially suicidal.
Third, guns are common in the United States (more than one third of U.S. households contain a firearm) and are lethal. A suicide attempt with a firearm rarely affords a second chance. Attempts involving drugs or cutting, which account for more than 90% of all suicidal acts, prove fatal far less often.
The empirical evidence linking suicide risk in the United States to the presence of firearms in the home is compelling.3 There are at least a dozen U.S. case–control studies in the peer-reviewed literature, all of which have found that a gun in the home is associated with an increased risk of suicide. The increase in risk is large, typically 2 to 10 times that in homes without guns, depending on the sample population (e.g., adolescents vs. older adults) and on the way in which the firearms were stored. The association between guns in the home and the risk of suicide is due entirely to a large increase in the risk of suicide by firearm that is not counterbalanced by a reduced risk of nonfirearm suicide. Moreover, the increased risk of suicide is not explained by increased psychopathologic characteristics, suicidal ideation, or suicide attempts among members of gun-owning households.
Three additional findings from the case–control studies are worth noting. The higher risk of suicide in homes with firearms applies not only to the gun owner but also to the gun owner's spouse and children. The presence of a gun in the home, no matter how the gun is stored, is a risk factor for completed suicide. And there is a hierarchy of suicide risk consistent with a dose–response relationship. How household guns are stored matters especially for young people — for example, one study found that adolescent suicide was four times as likely in homes with a loaded, unlocked firearm as in homes where guns were stored unloaded and locked.
Many ecologic studies covering multiple regions, states, or cities in the United States have also shown a strong association between rates of household gun ownership and rates of completed suicide — attributable, as found in the case–control studies, to the strong association between gun prevalence and gun suicide, without a counterbalancing association between gun-ownership levels and rates of nongun suicide. We recently examined the relationship between rates of household gun ownership and suicide in each of the 50 states for the period between 2000 and 2002.4 We used data on gun ownership from a large telephone survey (of more than 200,000 respondents) and controlled for rates of poverty, urbanization, unemployment, mental illness, and drug and alcohol dependence and abuse. Among men, among women, and in every age group (including children), states with higher rates of household gun ownership had higher rates of firearm suicide and overall suicides. There was no association between firearm-ownership rates and nonfirearm suicides. To illustrate the main findings, we presented data for the 15 states with the highest levels of household gun ownership matched with the six states with the lowest levels (using only six so that the populations in both groups of states would be approximately equal). In the table, the findings are updated for 2001 through 2005.
|
The recent Supreme Court decision may lead to higher rates of gun ownership. Such an outcome would increase the incidence of suicide. Two complementary approaches are available to physicians to help counter this possibility: to try to reduce the number of suicide attempts (e.g., by recognizing and treating mental illness) and to try to reduce the probability that suicide attempts will prove fatal (e.g., by reducing access to lethal means). Many U.S. physicians, from primary care practitioners to psychiatrists, focus exclusively on the first approach. Yet international experts have concluded that restriction of access to lethal means is one of the few suicide-prevention policies with proven effectiveness.5
In our experience, many clinicians who care deeply about preventing suicide are unfamiliar with the evidence linking guns to suicide. Too many seem to believe that anyone who is serious enough about suicide to use a gun would find an equally effective means if a gun were not available. This belief is invalid.
Physicians and other health care providers who care for suicidal patients should be able to assess whether people at risk for suicide have access to a firearm or other lethal means and to work with patients and their families to limit access to those means until suicidal feelings have passed. A Web site of the Harvard Injury Control Research Center can help physicians and others in this effort (www.hsph.harvard.edu/means-matter). Effective suicide prevention should focus not only on a patient's psychological condition but also on the availability of lethal means — which can make the difference between life and death.
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
Source Information
Dr. Miller is the associate director and Dr. Hemenway the director of the Harvard Injury Control Research Center, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston.
References
If history is a guide, this is a good omen, IHMO.
Nanny State Ping.
Japan has a much higher suicide rate. They must have more access to guns, that would explain it!
That makes perfect sense. The only reason the homicide numbers aren't higher is because in many instances homicides are prevented by the presence of another gun.
It seems I've read somewhere that more crimes are prevented by a homeowner brandishing a firearm than are committed.
In gun-free Japan, the per-capita suicide rate is several times that of America.
I agree it is a very bad idea to keep a loaded gun in the house.
It's much better to keep multiple loaded guns throughout the house so they are easily accessible no matter where you are or what the circumstances.
:-)
Want to drive the MSM crazy? Buy as many guns as you can afford between now and November. That should get them thinking.
I think a lot of physician assisted suicide “doctors” are starting to become concerned about something that might cause a decrease in their business. Like everyone else, they really need the money. They have mouths at home to feed.
People kill people.
My mother killed herself with a gun. She planned it out for over a week. If she hadn’t had a gun, she would have used pills or another method. Blaming guns is just silly.
And 100,000 patients die a needless death every year in hospitals because of mistakes caused by doctors.
Therefore, these pompous quacks should shut their damn pie holes about the Second Amendment and firearms, of which they know nothing. These MD types should get their OWN act together.
Here is the WHO list alphabetically.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate
Wikipedia sorted it, the USA is something like 49th rank globally, and most of the people that “beat” us don't allow citizens to mess around with guns like we do here.
OK, someone do a quick “peer review” and I'll collect the charge for doing this “study”.
NEJM’s study from ‘99 worked this way- they reviewed police reports, and when they found a suicide by gun, they went a certain distance away, and checked to see if the people living there had committed suicide by gun or had a gun. They then corrected this for age, race, gender and income (without explaining how). They arrived at the startling conclusion that you were 40 times more likely to commit suicide using a gun, than if you didn't have a gun. There were several flaws with the data but it was cited here.
I checked my gun club, where almost everyone owns a gun, and checked with the clubs we affiliate with, and found the suicide rate over ten years to be zero (unless you count two DUI car accidents). That must mean there is a population somewhere with a huge suicide rate, to make up the 40x rate!
My mom didn’t have a gun. Pills did the trick quite to her desire.
Ping? Maybe after Sarah Palin’s speech.
Why post that when the real McCoy was free, open access? If their conclusion were otherwise, I doubt it would have been a FReebie.
This is absolute BS, the Suicide rate in this country has shown no significant change in the past 50 years. suicidal people will kill themselves regardless of their access or lack of access to a gun.
Understandable, good sir!
From memory; Murders by firearm and suicides by firearm are about the same percentage.
Looks like these dweebs could use a critique of their poorly researched article.
David Hemenway, PhD
Director, Email: hemenway@hsph.harvard.edu
Matthew Miller, MD, MPH, ScD
Associate Director, Harvard Injury Control Research Center Email: mmiller@hsph.harvard.edu
These stupid b@$t@rds don't seem to know about the studies that have been published that it's WILL POWER that causes the suicide, not the instrument. Guns don't CAUSE suicide, they're an instrument of suicide. Scientists who don't understand cause and effect? Sure glad none of these G-d D@mned idiots are my physician. Or, as you put it:
In gun-free Japan, the per-capita suicide rate is several times that of America.
Bang List ping
I realize things have got to be pretty rough for a person to take their own life, but I tend to get a bit angry with folks who use a gun.
I know two brothers who did this about 15 years apart. Both had families and both shot themselves in their homes. This leaves a horrible visual scene for their families to discover. One of the brothers laid out a sheet, sat down on it and shot himself in the head. He must have watched too much TV and thought he’d have just a tiny hole and maybe a pool of blood, but in reality, he did have a tiny little hole at the entrance and a huge gaping exit hole where it blew bone, skin and brain matter all over the walls for his family to clean up.
Thanks for the addies.
“People shouldn’t be allowed to kill themselves. That is practicing medicine without a license!”
I am pretty sure that more than 46 murders AND more than 46 rapes are prevented by the potential victim packing heat. And that does not even factor in would be assaults, cougar and bear attacks (especially jogging in California). Thus by the harm NOT committed, guns should be kept.
Thanks for the links.
From Medscape Today (date unknown):
“SUICIDE
The overall physician suicide rate cited by most studies has been between 28 and 40 per 100,000, compared with the overall rate in the general population of 12.3 per 100,000.[1] Overall, then, physicians are more than twice as likely as the general population to kill themselves. Each year, it would take the equivalent of 1 to 2 average-sized graduating classes of medical school to replace the number of physicians who kill themselves. This rate appears higher than among other professionals.[2]”
Perhaps the JAMA should examine their own problems.
Doctors kill people.
THE QUITTER
When you’re lost in the Wild, and you’re scared as a child,
And Death looks you bang in the eye,
And you’re sore as a boil, it’s according to Hoyle
To cock your revolver and . . . die.
But the Code of a Man says: “Fight all you can,”
And self-dissolution is barred.
In hunger and woe, oh, it’s easy to blow . . .
It’s the hell-served-for-breakfast that’s hard.
“You’re sick of the game!” Well, now, that’s a shame.
You’re young and you’re brave and you’re bright.
“You’ve had a raw deal!” I know — but don’t squeal,
Buck up, do your damnedest, and fight.
It’s the plugging away that will win you the day,
So don’t be a piker old pard!
Just draw on your grit; it’s so easy to quit:
It’s the keeping-your-chin-up that’s hard.
It’s easy to cry that you’re beaten — and die;
It’s easy to crawfish and crawl;
But to fight and to fight when hope’s out of sight —
Why, that’s the best game of them all!
And though you come out of each gruelling bout,
All broken and beaten and scarred,
Just have one more try — it’s dead easy to die,
It’s the keeping-on-living that’s hard.
Robert Service, 1907
She backed down immediately.
This was “debunked” years ago. Why hasn’t this guy done his homework?
Naw, I've been doing that fer years and it hasn't worked yet!
This journal has for a very long time as a matter of editorial policy been pro-actively opposed to our exercise of the rights secured under the Second Amendment.
Let's convert those typed NUMBERS to digits: between 33.3% & 80%.
With that large a variance, at the beginning of the study, the rest must be, at least, 46.7% JUNK.
The gun store I frequent has had a lot of new customers come in for a hand gun. Many say it’s because they aren’t sure the next president will allow such purchases. They want one now while the purchase is still allowed.
Allowed? A Constitutional right is a right above a law and a government. Infringement of the right is a call to tell those who would govern us to back off.
More commit suicide from drugs they’ve been prescribed by doctors.
For the FreeRepublic "banglist", please click HERE .
Morons. Guns no more cause suicides than pencils cause misspelled words.
So we are going to affect the lower 10% by attacking your guns.
What idiots.
I hear the same things every weekend in the shop. People are scarfing up the sunset-'black guns' as fast as they can. The fear is that NObama will reinstate the AWB no matter what Heller says in the interest of 'public safety'.
Even the post-ban guns are getting purchased, which is unusual. Heller was definitive, but a few doors opened up for 'some controls', which will be interpreted liberally by the anti-gunners, and narrowly by the pro-gun crowd.
I think they were referring to attempted suicides, not successful suicides.
Sad but true.
What brand of firearm "causes" the most suicides?
How many of the suicide victims consulted a doctor within a month before the attempt?
Does this means that doctors cause suicides?
Because these guys want to make sure only doctor-assisted suicide is legal.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.