Posted on 08/11/2010 11:37:46 AM PDT by Borges
RIP.
I saw Roots on TV a couple of years ago. I laughed through most of it because it was so predictable and the writers made sure every white character was the stereotypical southern redneck. All slaveowners were evil-— Ed Asner and Robert Reed (Mr. Brady) were rapists. And Sandy Duncan’s character was the ditzy southern belle only interested in ballgowns.
Re: “ I remember the hoopla, but I never saw the series, I wonder how many of the white deaths and rapes at the hands of blacks result from that kind of message being constantly hammered into their consciousness over the last 45 years.”
****************
I remember the big to-do about that series that I refused to watch — what a crock —
Some of our teachers made us watch it. Sure helped the ratings.
RE: “IIRC, Alex Haley stole the idea from another author who had written a book about Jewish families escaping the slavery of the Nazis.
He then changed everything to match some fictional fantasy he had concocted about America’s early history and slavery.
I don’t believe that there is ONE SINGLE FACTUAL event, nor person, in the entire book, or movie.”
***************
Agree — no ‘facts’ in Roots —
It’s right up there with that other mess — “Dances with Wolves,” or, as my late father called it, “Dances with Facts.”
RE: “Lonesome Dove is the best miniseries ever produced for TV. Period. Nothing else is even close.”
*************
What??? You didn’t like The Thorn Birds???? LOL
Just couldn’t get into it...... :-)
No one claimed ‘Dances With Wolves’ was anything but fiction.
RE: “No one claimed ‘Dances With Wolves’ was anything but fiction.”
************
My late father, a huge fan of and expert on the timeframe this ‘story’ took place, said nothing rang true and though it may not have been presented as ‘fact’ by Hollwood, people who know better tend to be insulted when there are no real facts presented.
Then there’s the little matter of Kevin Costner’s lack of talent but that’s another story.
Wrong black guy, stupid. Scratch that comment.
It’s fiction from start to finish and fiction never lies. If you wanted fact watch a documentary on the period.
RE: “It’s fiction from start to finish and fiction never lies. If you wanted fact watch a documentary on the period.”
*****************
I did not see the film. Many did, including my father, and found it laughable from reports here in Hollywood.
What’s your problem anyway? Kind of overly prickly over a simple comment I made about a movie. If you set a film or TV show or whatever in a certain timeframe and then nothing about it rings true, it seems a little silly. But hey, maybe that’s just ME.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.