Posted on 11/05/2011 12:54:18 PM PDT by Hunton Peck
Thanks Hunton Peck.
Ummm. No. Just google ‘windmill bird deaths’ and you will get many pro and con stories. Just a brief reading gives 10,000 to 40,000 bird deaths per year in the U.S. alone. Turbines exist in other countries as well. One facility in Wolfe Island off the shores of Kingston, Ont., Canada, has 86 turbines. Each wind turbine averages 14 bird kills per year and 29 bat kills. That amounts to 1032 birds killed per year and 2540 bats killed.
Millions of birds die each year by unnatural causes, so the number of 40,000 in the U.S. pales by comparison. I don’t know what the deaths worldwide are. But just because the national number is much lower does not mean that it is non-existent or unimportant.
Perhaps 400,000 is a worldwide number?
Your vocabulary is loathsome. It suggests to me that you are a ledgend in your own miniscule mind.
Get back to us after you sober up.
EOF
Murphy always rears his ugly head.
Perhaps not Murphy. Perhaps it was intentional.
I had a feeling the reports of a low-cost solution were probably bunk. Thanks for the info.
I apologize if I seemed to be saying that bird deaths due to wind machines are "non-existent or unimportant". As one who, during my time as a wildlife rehabilitator, hand-raised a score or more injured/orphaned birds for weeks or months each until they are ready to be released, I know that every single one of those lives are God-given and precious.
Wind power at small scales has been around for centuries, and any American farmer will tell you that prior to FDR's Big-Government New Deal REA, a lot of America's rural heartland relied on wind power. I personally think that while modern small-scale wind power is both practical and worthwhile, the large-scale projects tend to be troublesome boondoggles.
Anyway, my point before was that bird kills are not a good means for advocating against large-scale wind power.
The number of birds actually killed by wind machines is a) mostly unknown, due to lack of data, and b) a lot smaller than the figures usually fabricated by the anti-wind-power advocates. In that information vacuum, people with agendas make data up. I have seen figures taken from a small study done on some turbines that were (unfortunately) sited directly on a major migration path, and multiplied by the estimated number of turbines in the world, as if they all were in such paths. That's silly at best, and a better description is "fraudulent".
> Perhaps 400,000 is a worldwide number?
It could be. As above, I don't know the real numbers any better than those who fabricate them; I believe it's lower than often cited, because no one is able to show the carcasses, and if birds were being knocked out of the sky at the cited rates, there would be piles of them on every wind farm.
Your mention of bat kills is interesting. I personally like bats a lot, and hadn't thought wind machines posed a significant danger to them, given that they are known to be able to fly through rotating electric fan blades and so on. I'll look into that, and thank you for the thought.
Bat mortality is significantly higher thanks to the poor siting of wind turbines and reckless operating procedures (during peak migration periods). Turbines are adding to the devastation already underway from white nose syndrome.
We're long past the point of trying to stop wind projects using bird/bat mortality. The public is too confused by available information — as clearly shown in your post. Still, the industry knows better but refuses to accept responsibility and our wildlife agencies (State and Local) are unwilling to stand up for fear they will lose their jobs. The question now is how much mortality will take place before the industry succumbs to the more obvious weakness — the fact that the wind cannot survive without billions paid out in federal subsidies and existing state mandates that enable developers to demand (and get) higher prices for a low-value energy.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.