Maybe, or perhaps from other strategies.
Posted on 10/14/2013 8:38:08 AM PDT by null and void
They also know what “ungawa” means. Pretty smart critters.
The evidence would be enormous.
Such a civilization wouldn't just spring up out of nowhere, going instantly from the Stone Age to 21st Century (at least) technology. It would take thousands of years and a population base of at least hundreds of millions of people. Such a civilization would leave worldwide evidence.
A trivial example: glass bottles, when buried, can last essentially unchanged for hundreds of thousands of years.
Another example: the amount of metal used in a modern city would leave traces in the soil and rock that could still be detected millions of years later. Even if your hypothetical city recycled to an extent that would make environmental activists giddy with joy, they still would have had cities in their past that didn't have the technology to do so.
If there had been a highly technological civilization prior to 10,000 years ago, we would have found traces (and more) of it by now.
Yup. All my dogs look at my finger.
It's certainly not compelling as far as mainstream archaeology is concerned...!
And then there are the Great Pyramids, again there are good arguments that those could not have been built by a (mostly) stone age people, re the 2500 BC Egyptians.
http://www.skepdic.com/pyramidiocy.html
Harsh, but fair.
The older cities would be mined for the metals, and the remaining traces after enough weathering could easily be taken as ore deposits.
Yes, there should be hard evidence, and yes, there are many OOPArts out there, and yes, we do try very hard to fit them into our current world view, or they get filed and forgotten.
Keep in mind that I am speculating, not advocating the certainty of an antediluvian society, but merely allowing the possibility that one could have existed, as yet undiscovered and/or unrecognized.
A post collapse religious fervor could even have gone to great efforts to eliminate every trace of any previous technology or civilization, no library of Alexandria, no statue of Buddha is immune.
My dog doesn’t look at my finger. He turns his head and look to where my finger is pointing.
Antediluvian isn’t the precise word I want, but if you’ll allow the water in the Great Flood to be frozen, it can be hammered in to place, filed flush, and painted to match...
What do you do with humans when they are overpopulated and eating everything in sight?
I'm skeptical that we could hide the evidence of our civilization from future archaeologists, even were we to devote an enormous effort in to doing so.
Yes, there should be hard evidence, and yes, there are many OOPArts out there, and yes, we do try very hard to fit them into our current world view, or they get filed and forgotten.
That's the first time I'd ever come across that term ("OOPArt").
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Out-of-place_artifact
Keep in mind that I am speculating, not advocating the certainty of an antediluvian society, but merely allowing the possibility that one could have existed, as yet undiscovered and/or unrecognized.
One can't prove a negative, of course, but it strikes me as extraordinarily unlikely. And, as they say, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
A post collapse religious fervor could even have gone to great efforts to eliminate every trace of any previous technology or civilization, no library of Alexandria, no statue of Buddha is immune.
Shades of Asimov's "Nightfall"!
Hes talking about the last great flood. We all live in the regeneration of the last great catastrophe. This is the only answer to the question that science will not adress and has no way to explain.
Question....How did the oldest civilization on the planet (Sumer according to scientists) have all the arts, science, math, writing, medicine, agriculture, world maps, sea navigation, astronomy, pictures of the solar system, etc ?
Answer....they got it from the previous civilization.
You beat me to it!
Every dog I ever had automatically knew what pointing meant and knew it related to a direction.
Ours would be extraordinary difficult to hide. Stuff in Clarke orbits could still be there when we are no longer recognizable as our current species.
That's the first time I'd ever come across that term ("OOPArt").
FR, an opportunity to learn something every day...
And, as they say, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
Yep. I'm open to such evidence being found. Until then, it's just speculative fiction/fantasy.
Shades of Asimov's "Nightfall"!
Opposite, really. In Nightfall the church tried to provide continuity.
A blend of militant islam and wacko environmentalism, with a leavening of Luddites, rage, and post collapse PTSD-like insanity wouldn't leave much behind.
One usually doesn't see "Great Flood" and "legitmate archaeology" in the same conversation...
Question....How did the oldest civilization on the planet (Sumer according to scientists) have all the arts, science, math, writing, medicine, agriculture, world maps, sea navigation, astronomy, pictures of the solar system, etc ? Answer....they got it from the previous civilization.
I have to call shenanigans on this one; are you seriously asserting that ancient Sumer had "pictures of the solar system" and world maps? As for some of the rest (arts, math, etc.) it doesn't require an antediluvian civilization. People (such as the Sumerians) were perfectly capable of inventing such things as writing on their own.
Note to self, never flip off an elephant.
“What do you do with humans when they are overpopulated and eating everything in sight?”
That one is too easy. Start a major war.
Next?
Sadly enough, elephants are to civilized for that...
Not so. In the short story, there was a group known as the Cult which used their scriptures to predict the Nightfall itself. While they were in fact correct, they didn't want to preserve civilization...that was the goal of a group of scientists.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.