Posted on 04/25/2017 4:43:34 AM PDT by Kaslin
Six anti-free speech Democrats have done the unthinkable in the State of North Carolina. They have voted to prevent HB 527 from passing through the higher education committee and onto the house floor for a full vote. Dubbed as a bill to “Restore and Preserve Campus Free Speech,” it is difficult to understand how anyone could be opposed, regardless of his political persuasion. (For more details on HB 527, click here).
The need for HB 527 is clear given that only one UNC campus, UNC-Chapel Hill, has been rated by the non-partisan Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) as a green-light school. Green light schools are those universities with no policies that violate the First Amendment. Every university in America should be a green light university. Regrettably, there are less than two-dozen in the entire nation.
An astounding 11 campuses in the UNC system have been designated by FIRE as yellow light schools. Schools ranked as yellow light have at least one policy that is sufficiently vague that it could be used to quash First Amendment protected speech. The remaining four UNC campuses were designated as red light, which means they have at least one policy that clearly and substantially impairs free speech.
Individual cases of free speech violations are not difficult to find in the UNC system. Just last year, North Carolina State University in Raleigh, which has a yellow light ranking, was forced to overhaul some of its policies after being successfully sued by a student organization named Grace Christian Life. In that case, the plaintiffs decided to sue after group members were informed that they needed a permit to talk about religion with students while handing out flyers on campus.
In addition to the clear substantive problem with the permit policy, the evidence showed that it was being applied to Grace Christian Life but not to secular organizations. This is in stark violation of the obligation of the university to remain viewpoint neutral in its treatment of student groups. (In my view, the Unites States Constitution is the only permit students need to show to these petty government officials before they decide to speak on a public university campus).
In the absence of guiding legislation, N.C. State was forced to settle the case in July of 2016. As a result, they were forced to pay the plaintiff’s legal fees. They were also forced to discontinue the school’s permit policy for non-commercial solicitation on campus. This case alone demonstrated the lack of competence in the UNC Office of General Counsel, which insists on defending patently unconstitutional policies at taxpayer expense.
HB 527 directs the UNC Board of Governors to adopt a campus-wide policy stating that, “The primary function of each constituent institution is the discovery, improvement, transmission, and dissemination of knowledge by the means of research, teaching, discussion, and debate.” The bill also stipulates the following:
Who could possibly object to any of these basic principles of free expression? Well, six elected Democrats did. Having listened to the audio from the committee hearing on HB 527, it is evident to me that members voting against the bill are doing so at the behest of UNC’s ideologically driven legal counsel. To put it mildly, the audio strongly suggests that some members have not read the bill and are relying on the advice of bad lawyers.
Just in case you are wondering, the names of the Democrats who have temporarily killed HB 527 are listed below:
Rep. Becky Carney can be contacted here.
Rep. Henry Michaux can be contacted here.
Rep. Rodney Moore can be contacted here.
Rep. Brian Turner can be contacted here.
Rep. Edward Hanes can be contacted here.
Rep. Verla Insko can be contacted here.
Over the years, I have provided numerous examples of why we need such legislation. Opponents must now explain the downside of reigning in a system that consistently fails to make passing grades on an issue as fundamental as freedom of speech. If they cannot provide credible examples of how this legislation would hurt the universities then they need to change their votes.
The fundamental law of the land is the United States Constitution, not the university handbook. We need legislation to teach our educators that basic principle, which every teenager should grasp before enrolling in college.
Please Freepmail me, if you want to be added, or removed from the ping list.
If Trump and the Republicans do not hit this issue hard, who will? They are more at fault than the Democrats.
We lost out with the expression TEA party when we stopped using the. Acronym for "Taxed Enough Already" its original meaning and allowed the left to mock us with many other meanings of "tea." We can take power from words.
I prefer the term Pro-fa
Pro Fascists.
Use out own words, no parentheses
The very fact that any legislation is even necessary to affirm the First Amendment is perverse, thanks of course, to the vile, perverted, and evil scum that comprise the Demonic Party.
Excellent!
If US attorney’s had the testicular fortitude to prosecute these university officials who are government employees of violating free speech constitutionally guaranteed civil rights, these state laws would not be necessary. At Berkeley, you could indict them as a conspiracy group, the President of the University, the Dean, the campus police chief and some key underlings. It should happen but then again it would take testicular fortitude.
One of the few good lawyers. Thank you Mr. Adams. Most people have no idea what goes on in the liberal farts departments. They are destroying higher education.
Really. So the republicans are the real enemies? Mr. Adams, a republican, is also the real enemy too? This is precisely what the old media empire proclaims.
I am not clear on the party-proportional makeup of the NC legislature, nor the point in the legislative process the bill has gone thus far, so what I don’t understand is how six Dim reps alone killed the bill.
I suppose it depends on how many rats are in the majority.
They voted to kill the bill in committee. Read the first two sentences.
That's why I made that meme... it's too fitting! :)
That will get their panties in a wad for sure.
Your AntiFA Meme stating Anti First Amendment and Anti Free Assembly is terrific!
How the hell can the minority party stop something from getting out of committee?
Answer, they can’t. The bill failed 6-6 because 2 Republicans were absent.
You’re right. Something is fishy.
Thanks!
After we turned the 'Fake News' label on the left, now we can totally rebrand AntiFA.
I love it!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.